This category contains 259 posts

MLB Homicides

Lyman BostockWhen discussing MLB suicides last week, I said that I couldn’t understand anyone’s suicidal thought process. Well, I don’t have any better understanding of murder. Sure, there’s a crime of passion element. And simple research points to a connection between murder and socio-economic standing. But, c’mon. I don’t get it – the thought process or lack thereof that would allow someone to take the life of another. And the truth is that when dealing with a sample of five, as we are today, all of the trends go out the window. These are just five awful anecdotes.

Greg HalmanPlaying his first professional game when he was just 16, Greg Halman was a power hitting outfield prospect who smacked 110 home runs over the four minor league seasons leading up to his first promotion to the bigs in 2010. While in Seattle, the Dutch righty struggled with -0.4 WAR over 121 plate appearances in 2010 and 2011. On November 21, 2011, he was killed by his brother Jason in the Rotterdam apartment they shared. Nine months later, Jason was released by Dutch courts because he suffered from psychosis at the time of the killing. Wright Thompson wrote a thoughtful, detailed, and chilling account of the relationship between the brothers at ESPN that I highly recommend.

Dernell StensonDernell Stenson was a corner outfielder for the Reds. Not a big prospect, Stenson appeared in his only 37 games during the 2003 season, hitting three homers and totaling 0.1 WAR. That November, Stenson was kidnapped, bound, shot multiple times, and run over with his own car. Four men were charged with multiple crimes. Three were convicted. Two weeks prior to his kidnapping and murder, an ex-girlfriend, Jennifer R. Gaddis, sent him a disturbing text message saying, “U better pray I never see you U again. I swear Dernell U R worth a Murder charge 4 & that is all U R worth.” However, it was determined she was not connected to the crime.

In the 1990s, Gary, Indiana was sometimes called the murder capital of the United States. On September 23, 1978, Lyman Bostock, an Angel and former Twin, after going 2-4 with a double and a walk in a losing effort against the White Sox, was murdered there. Bostock was a star at the plate, batting .311 and totaling 13.0 WAR over his first four seasons in the majors. On that day in Gary, was visiting his uncle, Ed Turner. With Turner driving and two women in the car, Bostock rode in the back seat. The estranged husband of one of the women, Leonard Smith, drove up to the car and began his jealous rage. Turner drove away. But at a traffic light, Smith pulled up and fired his shotgun into the back seat. Though he said the shot was intended for his wife, he hit Bostock. After one mistrial, Smith was found not guilty by reason of temporary insanity. He was sentenced to psychiatric care and released less than one year later. For more information, read Tim Connaughton’s SABR biography on Bostock.

By the way, though it’s a sample of only three people at this point, and only one in the United States, two of the above murderers spent no time in jail. A quick internet search reveals a 1991 study commissioned by the National Institute of Mental health that says an insanity defense is only used in about 1% of county court cases. And it’s successful in only 26% of those. Just like in baseball, don’t let a sample of three cases make you believe differently.

Miguel FuentesThe Seattle Pilots played for only one season before moving to Milwaukee and becoming the Brewers in 1970. Miguel Fuentes threw their final pitch. All told, Fuentes tossed 26 innings over eight games, four of them starts. He won once and finished the year and his career with 0.0 WAR. After the MLB season, he went home to pitch in the Puerto Rican Winter League. After that season ended, Fuentes was in a bar in his hometown of Loiza Aldea. Apparently there was a plumbing problem in the bathroom, so Fuentes went outside to relieve himself. As the story is told, he did so too close to someone’s car. Fuentes was shot and killed. I do not know the identity of his murderer. I am not sure if it is known.

Ed MorrisTwo pitchers in MLB history have been named Ed Morris. The one who was murdered is not the one who I sometimes call the best pitcher ever with that surname. This pitcher was a righty. After a cup of coffee with the 1922 Cubs, Morris pitched for the 1928-1931 Red Sox, totaling 42 wins and 7.4 WAR. Before spring training in 1932, a group of Morris’ friends threw a fish fry in his honor. An argument between Morris and fellow guest Joe White broke out. During the scuffle, White pulled a knife and stabbed Morris in the chest.


MLB Suicides

Willard HershbergerI do not claim to understand suicide any better than the next person. I do think those of us who have never had suicidal ideation should be very thankful, and those who have probably still should not suggest they understand what any other person is going through. Five active Major Leaguers have committed suicide, none since 1940. In this post, we’ll look at those five players, how they fared on the field, how they ended their lives, and how we can find out more about them.

Willard Hershberger was Ernie Lombardi’s backup behind the plate for the 1938-1940 Cincinnati Reds. He posted 2.0 WAR and died during the 1940 season, his suicide very much tied to his baseball career. With his Reds in first place in July, Lombardi was out. Hershberger replaced him, the Reds began to lose, and Hershberger blamed himself in multiple conversations with teammates and coaches. He told manager Bill McKechnie that he was going to commit suicide, just as his father had. Hershberger didn’t come to the next day’s doubleheader. He had slit his throat with a safety razor, becoming the only player ever to commit suicide during the season. Please check out Charles F. Faber’s biography of Hershberger.

Chick StahlKnown for a six hit game, for posting three triples in the first World Series, and for being the second ever manager of the Red Sox, Chick Stahl put up 31.7 WAR in his 10-year career, which lasted from 1897-1906. Bill James called him the 51st best center fielder ever in his New Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract, and he was the most successful player on this list. Dennis Auger’s SABR biography discusses theories as to reasons behind his suicide. It could have been stress related to the game. Perhaps it was a woman claiming to be pregnant with his child trying to force marriage upon him. Or maybe, as the Fort Wayne Journal-Gazette noted, he had been depressed and suicidal since 1889. Auger seems to suggest that a possible relationship with a man, or lack of such a relationship, could have caused Stahl’s ultimate demise. Whatever the case, drinking carbonic acid ended his life early in 1907.

Win Mercer was a talented pitcher from 1894-1902, posting a total of 28.9 WAR for four teams. He won 20+ games twice and had over 4 WAR three times. Overall, he won 132 games and was still just 28 when he died early in 1903. The outward reason for his suicide is even less clear for this fan favorite than for that of others on this list. Some say there was a suicide note, others disagree. If the note is real, it was said to have included a warning about the dangers of women and gambling. He killed himself by inhaling gas. Check out his SABR biography written by William Akin for more.

The chief backstop for the 1896-1899 Boston Beaneathers, Marty Bergen posted 339 hits and 0.0 WAR over his four seasons. Brian McKenna’s SABR biography of Bergen says that the catcher “ became increasingly despondent and irrational” over the course of his career. His son died in 1899 due to diphtheria. It’s hard to say whether it was the death of his son, what might have been the end of his career because of a hip injury, the hip surgery anesthesia from which his doctor said he never seemed to recover, or something else that ultimately made Bergen snap. He killed his wife and daughter with the blunt end of an axe, his son with the sharp side, and himself with a razor to the throat.

I don’t think Edgar McNabb, the 1893 Oriole pitcher who posted 1.1 WAR, necessarily counts as active since Bill James says he wasn’t asked to return to the team for the 1894 season. But since he was just 27 that season and not terrible, he’s included here. McNabb was having an affair with Louise Kellogg, the wife of R.E. Rockwell, the president of the Pacific and Northwest League. In the Pittsburgh Eiffel hotel on February 28, 1894, McNabb shot Kellogg either two or three times depending on the source. Then he turned the gun on himself. McNabb was found dead. Kellogg died two days later.


How Much Might Mike Trout’s Injury Hurt?

Mike Trout, SIYou’ve heard by now that Mike Trout is on the disabled list for the first time in his career. And no pun intended, this injury hurts the Trout loving community, which really should be all of us. I shamefully admit that I was checking BBREF on a daily basis to watch his 2017 WAR creep up. After all, we are in the middle of what could have been a historic season, certainly another 10 WAR season. But what now? Trout is out until near August, and I would expect that he won’t be right when he comes back. Thumb injuries can be like that.

So today I want to look at some kind of, sort of, maybe comparable players to see if they had a year like this. I want to see if there’s historical precedent for Trout to fall off track and get back on.

Mickey Mantle

In terms of career rankings, Mantle is the guy I’ve been aiming for since about 2014. At just age 25, Trout had set himself up to top Joe DiMaggio in center field, but catching Mantle would have been a real trick. Mantle wasn’t the healthiest guy ever. Even so, while in his 20s, he only missed more than a dozen games in a season once. It was that year, 1953, when Mantle was just 21, that he posted his worst season of the decade, just 5.3 WAR. He would never fall below 6.3 again, not until the injury plagued 1962 campaign. In 1963, after a Brooks Robinson fly ball and Mantle’s aggressive outfield play led to a broken bone in his foot and other issues, Mantle played just 65 games and totaled just 2.9 WAR. He was 31 and essentially done being the elite Mantle.

I don’t want to get into a deep Mantle-Trout debate right now – and there could be one. Trout needs at least half a dozen seasons of 9-win baseball in front of him to catch Mantle in terms of my MAPES ranking system. Sure, he could do that, but to get there, he’d have to repeat what he’s done so far, and then some. But here’s the debate. Mantle played at a time of poor integration. He didn’t face relief specialists. He only played against seven teams throughout his glory days, so he could become very familiar with the pitchers. He got to play through an expansion, a time when great players have all-time great seasons. And on and on.

Mantle hit his 534 career homers against 224 pitchers. That’s 2.38 per pitcher. Thus far, Trout has 184 homers against 134 pitchers. That’s 1.37 per pitcher, and it absolutely suggests that Trout has had a harder road in that one regard. For his career, Trout has hits against 401 different pitchers. Mantle did the same against only 427. And Mantle had over 6000 additional plate appearances.

Anyway, the only reasonable position to have on Trout and Mantle now is that one is a generational player. The other should be if healthy. Once Trout becomes that player, we can have a Mantle-Trout debate.

Roberto Clemente, 1956Roberto Clemente

I must say that if I’m Trout, I aim a bit higher than Clemente. Still, the Pirate right fielder is next on our list of comparison players because he’s not entirely dissimilar – an athletic outfielder whose chief skill is something other than power. Of course, at Trout’s level, you see how hard it is to compare him to anyone, as you’ll see below.

As it turns out, Clemente isn’t a great comparison. He wasn’t really healthy until he turned 25. Actually, through age-27 Clemente averaged just 4.2 WAR per 650 plate appearances. To this point, Trout’s at 9.5 per 650 trips. Once Clemente became Clemente in 1963, he remained largely healthy. And if Trout plays from here on like Clemente, he’d retire in a virtual tie with Stan Musial on my all-time list. For reference, that’s between Ted Williams and Eddie Collins.

Alex Rodriguez

Like Trout, A-Rod got started when he was very young. And like Trout, Rodriguez basically hit the ground running. There is some good news here. Through A-Rod’s age-24 season, he only topped 148 games played once. And once he was as low as 129. On the other hand, he wouldn’t dip below 124 until he was 35, which Trout will this year. And A-Rod wasn’t below 138 until he was 33. That was the year we stopped seeing elite A-Rod.

Albert Pujols

Angel fans don’t like this comparison because they see first-hand who Pujols has become. Through age-32, Pujols was basically never hurt, bottoming out at 143 games in 2006. In his eleven years in St. Louis, Albert never put up less than 5.3 WAR. Again, he was never hurt. Trout is.

Jimmie Foxx

By age-21, Foxx was about an 8-win player. He never missed meaningful time until a decade later. And even then, that was 124 games. It seems that these elite players just don’t have seasons where they miss the number of games Trout will miss this year.

Evan Longoria

There’s a real shot Longoria gets to the Hall of Miller and Eric one day. Among third basemen, he was ranked 30th all-time on my list coming into this season, and he’s probably passed a couple with his return to defensive form thus far in 2017. Also, I admit that Longo isn’t a great comparison, though he did begin his career with seasons of 4.8, 7.0, 8.1, and 7.4 WAR. Then in 2012, at the age of 26, he missed significant time with a hamstring injury, and he hasn’t been the same since. Before that season, he averaged 7.9 WAR per 650 trips to the plate. Since, it’s been a much more pedestrian 4.6.

Nomar Garciaparra

We forget how great Nomar was. Only eighteen players totaled more WAR from seasons two through five than Nomar. They’re all in the Hall or going, except maybe Barry Bonds and Dick Allen, both of whom are clearly over the line for me. Anyway, from 1997 through 2000, Nomar put up seasons of 6.6, 7.1, 6.6, and 7.4 WAR. He was only 26, and he was well on the way to a Hall of Fame career. Then a wrist injury struck. In 2002 and 2003, he again put up 6.8 and 6.1 WAR. Then came a groin injury, a trade to the Cubs, a Red Sox World Series win, and essentially the end of Nomar’s career. He went from 6.9 WAR per 650 plate appearances through 2003 to 1.5 per 650 after that.

Ted Williams

We know that the Splendid Splinter’s career was disrupted from 1943-1945 due to WWII. He was great before he left, and he was great when he came back. Then in 1950 he shattered his elbow in the All-Star Game. He was elite again in 1951, but in 1952 and 1953 he totaled only 43 games (and 2.3 WAR) because he was off in Korea. By the time he returned, he was 35. Yet, he still played seven more seasons at less than peak health averaging a cool 8.0 WAR per 650 trips to the plate.

Other Guys

Rickey Henderson, 1981Frank Robinson is another example; it wasn’t until age-36 that he had a season with fewer than 129 games played. The only thing that kept Mike Schmidt from playing a full schedule was the 1981 player strike. Mel Ott played in at least 120 games every year from the time he was 19 through the age of 36. Eddie Mathews’ first year with fewer than 134 games played was his last. Aside from missing 1945 due to military service, Stan Musial never played in fewer than 134 games until he was 38. Lou Gehrig, you might have heard, never missed a day. Rickey Henderson presents some hope. He played in only 95 games in 1987 because of a hamstring injury, yet was elite for three more years before dropping off at age-32 and remaining less than 100% healthy for much of the rest of his career.


So what have we learned? I don’t know. Not a lot, maybe. It seems that the elite, inner-circle guys among whom Mike Trout hopes his name is mentioned in 20 years, don’t have injuries like the one Trout is having this season. Yes, it’s a freak injury. No, I don’t expect it to linger into 2018. Still, among the greats, there’s more health than Mike Trout is having right about now. Let’s hope the ulnar collateral ligament in his right thumb is nothing more than a bump in the road. Those who look for daily WAR updates on BBREF are holding our collective breath.


Value-based HoME Standings

Miller and I love to get comments! Here’s one that grabbed me from one of our most loyal readers, Ryan, about the series of articles we recently posted about the HoME Standings. Those articles calculated standings solely based on playing time:

Do you have an alternative standings with a weighting of CHEWS+ values of each player for every franchise?

In a word, no. But it prompted me to put together standings based instead on the WAR values I compute. Thanks, Ryan!

Rather than run a three-article odyssey again, I’m going to sum things up in one post. This time around, I’ve based the standings on the percent of a player’s career spent with a given team. If Joe Schmuckface had 50 WAR with the Yanks and 50 WAR with the Sox, then each team gets 0.50 standings points assigned to them.

First off, let’s note that the standings by playing time included managers and executives who were specifically associated with teams in the roles we elected them for. And to answer another reader question, this time from JD, we elected Spalding as an executive. We didn’t feel that his case as an exec required the support of his playing career, unlike combo candidates Roger Bresnahan, Clark Griffith, and Frank Chance. In the same way, we didn’t include John McGraw and Connie Mack’s executive and/or player careers because they weren’t necessary for their election.

OK, on with the show.

The Grays Area

When we looked at the standings by playing time, several current MLB teams fell into what I coined “The Spiders’ Web.” These four clubs have so far failed to give HoMErs as much playing time as the highest-ranking defunct franchise, the Cleveland Spiders. But looking by value, the story is different in the details.

Five teams currently fall into “The Grays Area.” Among all long-dead franchises, The Providence Grays rank 26th among all clubs historically in our value-based standings. They received the contribution of 1.88 HoMErs, among whom were 76% of Old Hoss Radbourn’s value, 63% of Paul Hines’, 29% of Monte Ward’s, 13% of George Wright’s, and 7% of Jim O’Rourke’s.

The Toronto Blue Jays, 26th among current MLB teams are right behind them by 0.03 careers and are certain to pass them in 2019 at the latest. The Arizona Diamondbacks jump up a spot with 0.82 standings points. Only two defunct franchises stand between them and the Jays, the Buffalo Bisons (1.46) and the Detroit Wolverines (1.19). Ironically, these two teams shared a large number of core players. Two more dead teams separate the Colorado Rockies (0.65 careers) from their fellow Mountain Time foes. One is those famous old Baltimore Orioles teams of the 1890s, and the other is our old pals the Spiders. The Louisville Colonels and the Cleveland Infants of the Players League stand between the Rox and the Miami Marlins (0.51 careers). And then, a yawning gulf opens, and 24 cold, dead franchises sit above the Tampa Bay Rays who, to date have accumulated 0.1 careers’ worth of HoMErs. Better get cracking, Mantamen!

The Ring of Sixteen

Another target for expansion teams to aim for is “The Ring of Sixteen.” That is, catching up to one of the original franchises of the AL/NL peace accords of the 1910s. For Twins fans holding your breath, keep those cheeks puffed out because you’re about to get owned. The Houston Astros (4.73) trail the Twinkies by less than half of a single career, far less than what the Mets by in the playing-time version of our standings. The presence of Andy Pettitte, Roy Oswalt, and Carlos Beltran could very well get them there. The threats to the Ring of Sixteen loom less dangerously below the Stros. The New York Mets (3.27) probably don’t have enough HoME irons in the current fire to catch up very soon, even if we end up electing David Wright. But they will be well positioned to enter the 16 in the mid-term. The Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim and the Texas Rangers are tied with 2.97 HoMErs’ worth of value. The Metroplex Marshalls have a lot of little slices of careers out there to add as well as something like a third of Adrian Beltre’s career and half of Ian Kinsler’s plus a not-quite predictable piece of Cole Hamels. There’s a lot of opportunity for them if things break in their favor. The Halos are in something like the same boat but with more uncertainty. Like if Mike Trout leaves someday. Maybe they do need a stinkin’ badge?

Three more teams cluster up behind these three. The Washington Nationals (2.87) will have six years of Bryce Harper and a few years of Max Scherzer but little else to look forward to. I’d say they’re stuck in committee. The Kansas City Royals (2.75) are similar to the Nats. There’s no clear line of succession between Zack Greinke and the next Royals star. The last team in this little group is the San Diego Padres (2.61) whose missionary activities have attracted no HoME followers.

Rounding out the expansion group, the Seattle Mariners (2.32) and Milwaukee Brewers (2.25) have managed to haul themselves out of the gray area. The M’s have a whole bunch of third- or half-careers in the ready plus Ichrio. King Felix, and Kyle Seager bring more support. They could move quickly. And the Brew Crew continue to enjoy their status as a recognized MLB team.

Turning It Up to 10

Once we get into the Ring of 16, teams fall fairly neatly into two categories: those who have at least 10 careers worth of HoMErs, and those that don’t. The latter category comprises seven teams. As we mentioned early, the Minnesota Twins (5.12) lag far, far behind the other originals. The next squad on the horizon is nearly two full careers away, which is a lot considering how few careers were spent in the Twin Cities. Joe Mauer and Johan Santaña could take them a ways toward their next competitor, but they’ll still be short, and there’s little in the short- or mid-term climb, let alone keep the Astros at bay. Which means that the Cincinnati Reds (7.00) aren’t facing losing their spot in the Ring of Sixteen. The Reds aren’t in much better position than the Twins, but, thanks to nearly two decades of spectacular ineptitude, the Pittsburgh Pirates (7.65) won’t be in any position to scuttle the Redlegs’ hopes. Particularly if Andrew McCutchen is permanently broken. The Chicago White Sox (8.21) are in something of the same boat as the Reds and Bucs with relatively little near-term firepower. These three clubs will struggle among themselves for “supremacy” in the standings and won’t be reaching 10 players for a decade or more. Our next three teams, however, are knocking on the proverbial door.

Just three-quarters of a player away, the Baltimore Orioles (9.21) don’t have much to sing about with only guest shots by Jim Thome and Vlad Guerrero coming up. But Manny Machado seems very likely to earn them at least half of that 0.75 WAR they need to migrate northward. Relatively speaking, the St. Louis Cardinals (9.36) got a lot more playing time from their HoMErs than they did value. They rank sixth in our playing-time-base standings and 11th in value-based standings. But 10 careers is pretty much in the bag for the Redbirds. Albert Pujols gets them most of the way, and Scott Rolen and Carlos Beltran could put them over. If things break right, they might end up chirping about more than those guys too, but that’s up to the baseball gods, Adam Wainwright’s elbow, and Yadier Molina’s bat. Finally, the Philadelphia Phillies move up from 13th in playing time to 10th in value. They trail their former city mates, the A’s, by a shade more than 1 career, and they’ve got plenty in the pipeline among Rolen, Halladay, Thome, Hamels, and Chase Utley with Hughie Jennings, Cupid Childs, and Roy Oswalt representing opportunities for pick-ups as well. In the next three to five HoME elections, they’ll earn their tenth career. Speaking of the Oakland Athletics, at 10.56 careers, they’ve broken through a barrier, but they’ve got a lot of work to do to move up in the standings. Nearly two full careers separate them from the 8th place franchise. The White Elephants have some of Tim Hudson, and a bunch of HoME question marks who weren’t with them all that long. Expect a change in the standings here as the A’s cede the #9 slot to the Phils.

Four teams sit within a single HoME career of one another, and have a position from which to launch an assault on the top of the standings. The Cleveland Indians (12.41) have a couple careers’ worth of HoMErs in the near- and mid-term, plus a few younger players who could keep them climbing in the long term. They are running neck-and-neck with the Detroit Tigers (12.42). The Bengals counter with a lot of star power in Miguel Cabrera, Justin Verlander, Ian Kinsler, Max Scherzer, and several borderliners who could make it. I’d say they’ll keep ahead of the Tribe and might even be able to turn these guys into 6th place. That’s because the Boston Red Sox (13.32) and Atlanta Braves (13.37) sit within a single HoME career. For the sox it all depends on how long Dustin Pedroia, Jon Lester, David Price, and Chris Sale can continue to accumulate HoME credentials. Especially Pedroia, a lifetime Sock so far. Los Bravos have more than two careers’ worth of value coming their way in Chipper Jones, Andruw Jones, and Tim Hudson. That’ll keep all three teams below them from reaching 5th place. But will it get them into the “Gang of Four?”

The Gang of Four

The top four teams in our standings are separated by less than two HoME careers. The Braves have the Los Angeles Dodgers (14.31) under siege for the moment. But they probably can break it with Clayton Kershaw leading the charge. In the long term Seager, Bellinger, and Urias could propel them toward the top. The Chicago Cubs (14.55) are in trouble and will undoubtedly lose the 3rd spot. They might tumble to fifth and are at some risk of dropping into sixth place. They just don’t have many HoMErs coming along very soon. Most of their talent is too young to project a HoME career. The outlook is much rosier for the Evil Empire. The New York Yankees (15.75) have something like three careers’ worth of value simply awaiting our vote, and there’s more where those three came from. Lots more. They sit only one-half a career behind the top spot and will take it perhaps as soon as Andy Pettitte’s eligibility, if not Mariano’s. They will almost certainly become the first club with 20 HoME careers. That leaves us with the San Francisco Giants (16.25). Look, mostly in this country we all love to hate the Yankees. So does SF have any hope of holding off the Darth Vaders of MLB? Nope. The inevitable is going to happen unless our planet is destroyed first. I guess that’s one instance where I’d root for the Yanks. Heinie Groh and Carlos Beltran are their best near-term opportunities. Buster Posey, Madison Bumgarner, and Johnny Cueto have to nail down their claims to greatness first. A sudden and prolonged surge of great pitching from Matt Cain would help. Which isn’t much of a hope to offer. I guess bad money drives out good money. Or at least money that’s not as bad.

The Standings

Here then are the standings by value. You’ll find that we’ve added this information to our HoME Stats report on the honorees page. Enjoy.

     TEAM                   YEARS    HoMERS  /YEAR
 1 San Francisco Giants   1883–2017  16.25   0.15
 2 New York Yankees       1903–2017  15.74   0.14
 3 Chicago Cubs           1871–2017  14.55   0.10
 4 Los Angeles Dodgers    1884–2017  14.31   0.11
 5 Atlanta Braves         1871-2017  13.37   0.10
 8 Boston Red Sox         1901–2017  13.32   0.12
 7 Detroit Tigers         1901–2017  12.42   0.11
 8 Cleveland Indians      1901–2017  12.41   0.11
 9 Oakland Athletics      1901–2017  10.56   0.10
10 Philadelphia Phillies  1883–2017   9.43   0.07
11 St. Louis Cardinals    1882–2017   9.36   0.07
12 Baltimore Orioles      1901–2017   9.22   0.08
13 Chicago White Sox      1901–2017   8.21   0.07
14 Pittsburgh Pirates     1882–2017   7.65   0.06
15 Cincinnati Reds        1882-2017   7.00   0.05
16 Minnesota Twins        1901–2017   5.12   0.05
17 Houston Astros         1962–2017   4.73   0.10
18 New York Mets          1962–2017   3.27   0.07
19 LA Angels of Anaheim   1961–2017   2.97   0.06
20 Texas Rangers          1961–2017   2.97   0.06
21 Washington Nationals   1969–2017   2.87   0.07
22 Kansas City Royals     1969–2017   2.75   0.07
23 San Diego Padres       1969–2017   2.61   0.06
24 Seattle Mariners       1977–2017   2.32   0.07
25 Milwaukee Brewers      1969–2017   2.25   0.05
26 Toronto Blue Jays      1977-2017   1.85   0.05
27 Arizona Diamondbacks   1998–2017   0.82   0.06
28 Colorado Rockies       1993–2017   0.65   0.04
29 Miami Marlins          1993–2017   0.51   0.03
30 Tampa Bay Rays         1998–2017   0.01   0.00

Mount Rushmore, A Preview

Mount RushmoreNot long ago on New York’s WFAN, there was a conversation about the Mount Rushmore of the New York Jets. Now, I know some of you must be laughing, while others are think this is a mindless discussion. I was actually part of both groups. Luckily for me I was in the car for a while that day. I listened to passionate fans who really care about something that I at first thought was silly. The passion isn’t silly. But even if it were, these exercises are fun. They get people thinking.

And I’m a person, a Red Sox fan. So I got to thinking about the Red Sox. Ted Williams and Carl Yastrzemski are pretty easy. I’m not sure who the fourth guy should be maybe Pedro or Papi, Cy or Dewey. Boggs is fourth in Red Sox WAR. It’s the third guy who bugs me. See, I’m really not a Roger Clemens guy. And you can’t leave Clemens off any legitimate Mount Rushmore of the Red Sox.

Unless you can.

What I started thinking about why I don’t like Clemens, it’s simple. For his last four years in Boston, he really wasn’t the pitcher he had been. Then once he went to Toronto, he was. That’s it! Rushmore should be the best players ever to play for a franchise and only that franchise. That’s the only real way to remove Clemens from Boston’s, and it seems like it would be a lot of fun.

So, next Friday and basically for the 30 that follow, the Hall of Miller and Eric will share the Mount Rushmore for every franchise, awarding only based on the WAR of guys who have only played for that franchise. So you won’t find Ty Cobb on the Tigers’. Willie Mays doesn’t make it for the Giants. And Honus Wagner isn’t a Pirate. We think this could be quite interesting. Hope you enjoy.


Memorial Day

This is our national day of remembrance, and we thank all of our veterans whose lives were sacrificed in the protection of our democratic institutions, our liberty, and our safety. The baseball world doesn’t have a remembrance day, so we thought we’d take the opportunity to look back on some of the 80 ballplayers who died since Memorial Day 2016 (May 30th).

We can’t talk about every ballplayer who died because, frankly, we’d all be asleep. But we’ll list them all out and provide commentary as we are so moved. Please place your own remembrances, comments, and stray thoughts in the comments.

Obviously, we hope that the loved ones these men leave behind are comforted in their time of loss and understand the joy their ballplayer family member or friend brought to many millions of others.

  • Dick Adams
  • Red Adams
  • Bob Addis
  • Vic Albury
  • Gair Allie
  • Ruben Amaro, Sr.
  • Jose Arcia
  • Steve Arlin
  • John Barfield: No relation to Jesse and Josh.
  • Vic Barnhart
  • Juan Bell: Bad year for the 1980s Phils. Bell, Greg Jelks, and Dallas Green all goners.
  • Neil Berry
  • Bob Bowman
  • Ralph Branca: An acquaintance of mine is Ralph Branca’s niece…. Of course, Branca threw one of the ten most notorious pitches in MLB history. What are those other nine doomed pitches? Here’s some strong candidates:
    • Eddie Cicotte: Hitting Reds’ leadoff man Morrie Rath with the game’s first pitch indicated that the Black Sox fix was in.
    • Al Downing: Hank Aaron’s 1974 record-breaking homer had a similar effect, but in the racially charged 1970s, with Hammerin’ Hank receiving death threats as he approached the Babe’s 714 homers, the atmosphere was even more charged
    • Bump Hadley: Crushing Mickey Cochrane’s skull with a fastball and effectively ending his career.
    • Carl Mays: Killing Ray Chapman with a pitch in 1919, Major League Baseball’s lone on-field fatality
    • Donnie Moore: Allowed the Dave Henderson homer that sent the Angels’ hopes to hell in 1986. Especially notable because it haunted Moore for years until he took his own life
    • Tracy Stallard: Roger Maris homered, and the Babe was dethroned, asterisk be damned, ending an era of sorts.
    • Bob Stanley: The wild pitch that tied the score in the sixth game of the 1986 World Series, setting up the Buckner botch
    • Ralph Terry: Giving up Bill Mazeroski’s 1960 World Series game-seven winning walk-off homer
    • Mike Torrez: Bucky Dent’s homer to catapult the Yankees over the reeling Red Sox in the 1978 one-game playoff to decide the AL East
    • Tim Wakefield: Aaron Boone turned Wakefield’s 12th inning pitch into a walk-off playoff win.
    • Mitch Williams: Coughing up Joe Carter’s 1993 World Series game-six winning walk-off roundtripper
  • Alan Brice
  • Jackie Brown
  • Mark Brownson
  • Bob Bruce
  • Mike Brumley
  • Jim Bunning: I hate the Senator’s politics, but I love the pitcher’s career. An easy choice for the Hall of Miller and Eric, and a shame that the BBWAA couldn’t figure him out for the 15 years they kicked his name around. My various adjusted WAR for him shows four seasons with more than 7.0 WAR and another with 6.6. Tack onto those two 4.0+ seasons, one above 3.0, and four more above 2.0. His career is slightly more stretched out version of Juan Marichal’s, or a peakier Luis Tiant. Regardless, his career is plenty good enough for the HoME or any Hall worth its salt.
  • Putsy Caballero: Caballero means gentleman in Spanish. It can also mean a horseman in the southwestern US. Putsy (an alternative spelling of putzy) means stupid, idiotic, foolish. Which makes one wonder how Ralph Joseph Caballero from New Orleans got his nickname.
  • Chris Cannizaro: Poor guy. As a 24-year-old in 1962, he was rostered by the famously inept 1962 Mets. Then in 1969, at a more mature 31, he played for the inaugural Padres squad. He and his 68 OPS+ were the Friars’ lone All-Star representative. The honor could easily have devolved upon Nate Colbert (127 OPS+) or Al Ferrara (124 OPS+). In fairness, his OPS dropped 50 points from the time the voting was conducted to the actual game itself, then it collapsed again in the second half.
  • Eddie Carnett
  • Bob Cerv: Here’s one of those guys that made AL fans in the 1950s puke. Cerv could really hit, but the Yanks were lousy with outfielders, so they traded him to the KC A’s, also known to the AL as the unofficial farm team of the Yanks. There he proceeded to hit the dickens out of the ball for a couple years, at which point, the Yanks said “thanks for taking care of him, we’ll have him back now.” The Bombers got 8 homers and a 113 OPS+ as they patched over an injury to Roger Maris. They let him go in the expansion draft to the LA Angels, who promptly traded him back to the Bronx where he mashed down the stretch to help the Yanks breeze to the pennant and once more patch over injuries. The team could seemingly summon guys like Cerv, Enos Slaughter, Johnny Mize, or whoever they needed at will from some corner of the baseball world (usually KC), and those guys rarely sucked. Kinda like the 1990s–2000s Yanks, now that I think on it.
  • Bill Champion
  • Bryan Clutterbuck: Out of respect for those who have passed on, I’m not going to tell you exactly why I pause every time I see his name, but I suspect you can guess.
  • Choo-Choo Coleman: One of the great early Mets, famous, of course, for calling everyone “”
  • Marlan Coughtry: They don’t make names like this anymore. Straight out of central casting for tough-guy westerns.
  • Neil Dade
  • Joe DaMaestri: Sort of the Johnnie LeMaster of his day, without the awful moustache.
  • Bill Endicott
  • Leon Everitt
  • Jack Faszholz
  • Jose Fernandez: Obviously, a death representing both tragedy and the foolishness of youth. But if we play What If, can we say much about what the baseball world will miss out on? It’s very hard to say because Fernandez had already gone under the knife and had never reached 200 innings. His best campaign was his first, though none were too shabby. 38-17 with a 151 ERA+ for the Fish is pretty great. He could hit a little too. At 20 Fernando was his most comparable pitcher with Denis Eckersley and George Uhle also in the top ten. At 21 it shifted to Jack Stivetts, Mark Fidrych, he first Dutch Leonard, and Howie Pollett. At 22, Fidrych and Mark Prior plus Pollett once again. Fydrich and Prior = bad news. But after age 23 came an interesting mix include some incredible comps (Tom Seaver, Roger Clemens), some very good ones (Addie Joss and Mel Stottlemyre) and another warning sign (Herb Score). With pitchers, you always take the more conservative approach because it’s a game of survival, not merely ability. The Marlins and their fans would no doubt sign up for Joss (160-97, 45.9 WAR) or Stottlemyre (164-139, 40.6 WAR).
  • Chico Fernandez: Fernandez was a bad baseball player, -2.3 career WAR. But I mention him now because I hope that no one else in MLB from now until eternity will be known regularly as “” The word means “boy” in Spanish. (Although to be fair it can also be a nickname for Francisco.) We would never, ever call a player “boy” today, especially not an African-American. The last player I recall being referred to as “Chico” even a little bit was Jose Lind. I haven’t heard it since. Good riddance.
  • Dave Ferriss: Great hitting pitcher. He had MVP votes in 1945 and 1946, winning 46 games over the two years. His arm went south in 1947 and never recovered. He was done by 1950.
  • Todd Frohwirth: A submariner and a bullpen mainstay for two amazing years. Today his 1991–1993 stats look like a joke. He tossed 299 innings of 153 ERA+ baseball, including 106 frames in 1992. He saved only 11 games in his career despite his overall effectiveness. He had a massive platoon split to the tune of 175 points of OPS. His K/BB ratio against righties was 2.13:1 and 0.80 versus lefties.
  • Phil Gagliano
  • Ned Garver: Not to be confused with turn of the 20th Century hurler Ned Garvin. Garver’s record is pretty impressive despite its appearance: 129-157, 3.73 ERA, leading the AL in losses in 1949, hits allowed in 1955, and earned runs allowed in 1955. He mad just one All-Star team (1951) and never received a Cy Young vote (it wasn’t initiated until much of his career was over). He did finish second in the MVP voting for 1951, the one year he won 20 games and even picked up a stray vote the year before despite a 13-18 record with the lowly Browns. He pitched mostly for crappy teams, coming to the big leagues with the late 1940s Brownies, sliding over to the so-so Tigers of the mid 1950s, gliding toward retirement with the lowly KC A’s, and wrapping up with the expansion Angels in 1961. The underlying facts, however add up to a better pitcher than all that. My own systems indicate a candidate about as strong as Steve Rogers, Carl Mays, Eppa Rixey, Jesse Tannehill, and Mickey Welch. Yeah, not a HoMEr, but a pretty good. And less famous than any of those guys, except maybe Tannehill.
  • Dallas Green: I never liked Dallas Green. In fact, I still carry a grudge. Green hailed from some fictitious era and land of chest-thumping, red ass machismo. As a player Dallas Green was 20-22 with an 88 ERA+. A great basis from which to judge the performance of others. He destroyed the arms of Generation K because…Dallas Green. That was what real men did I guess. Soon after, he went back to the Phillies, where he’d worked for two decades in the 1960s and 1970s. He helped push Scott Rolen out of town by trash talking him in the press. “Scotty’s satisfied with being a so-so player. I think he can be greater, but his personality won’t let him.” Rolen, 27 at the time, was merely turning in the same excellent season he always did. But you know…Dallas Green (and fellow loudmouth, red-ass fool Larry Bowa who piled on). Rolen was dealt shortly after to the Cards. He was going to be a free agent at the end of the season, and Green led the organizational charge to ensure that the great third baseman wouldn’t resign. Green did some wonderful work to help get the Phillies a title in 1980 and the Cubs into the playoffs in the 1980s. But destroying three young arms and riding a team’s best player out on a rail seem like the kind of stupidity that should mar his reputation. Instead, upon his death, he was considered an outspoken baseball lifer or baseball man. Let’s hope that’s a dying breed because it sure looks like a synonym for jerk to me.
  • Doug Griffin
  • Vern Handrahan
  • Bill Hands: Little remembered today, from 1967–1973 Hands ran off a string of fine seasons, including an 8 WAR performance in 1969. He tossed 1547 innings of 126 ERA+ ball, never made an All0Star team, never got a Cy Young vote. With 30 pitching WAR, he’s very similar to Teddy Higuera and Mike Garcia, well known pitchers with relatively short careers but a very nice prime. Because Garcia was one of Cleveland’s four aces in the 1950s, Hands is probably the least well known of the three. But he was a fine, fine pitcher.
  • Phil Hennigan
  • Jim Hickman: In 1970 at 33, he came out of absolutely nowhere to throw down a 5.0 WAR season, get onto the All-Star team and finish 8th in the MVP voting for the Cubbies. Timing is everything, and that same performance just a year earlier would have gone a long way toward fending off the Amazin’ Hickman’s 1970 is amazingly anomalous compared to the rest of his career. His bat was worth +63 runs. He produced +43 of them in 1970. He had just one other season with more than 1.4 WAR in 1972 at 35 when he popped out 2.4 WAR for the Bruins thanks to another +15 batting runs. Which means that +58 of his +63 runs came in just two years. Pretty weird.
  • Mark Higgins
  • Hal Hudson
  • Greg Jelks: Not to be confused with the great Steve Jeltz on those amazing late-1980s Phillies squads.
  • Joe Kirrene
  • Steve Korcheck
  • Bob Kuzava
  • Jim Lehew
  • Stu Locklin
  • Turk Lown: At one time, the majors featured two Turks: Lown and Farrell. I’ve always conflated both of them with the infamous Turk Wendell of the tween-innings teeth-brushing. Lown is the worst pitcher of the three. Farrell and Wendell were actually pretty good.
  • Harry MacPherson
  • Andy Marte: Marte died this January in an automobile accident. Something happened to him in 2005 that derailed his career. Marte began his pro career at age 17 with the Braves’ rookie ball squad in the Appalachian League. He advanced a level a year, losing very little in his offensive slash line as he faced stiffer competition. Prospect mavens named him the #9 prospect in the minors before 2005. He stiffed as a 21-year old in a brief stint with parent club but continued to hit well in AAA. Before 2006, he was still the #14 prospect in the minors and was traded to Boston for Edgar Renteria and then flipped to Cleveland in a deal for CoCo Crisp. In Buffalo that year, he lost power and patience, in the majors, he flopped (though he showed some pop), and lost his place on prospect lists. The rest of his career was similar. Up and down and never really finding a foothold and, except for 82 games in AAA in 2009, never again as a younger player showed much of what made him a well-regarded prospect. I don’t know what happened. Was he injured in 2005? Was he out of shape? I remember rumors to that effect. Or is there really such thing as a Quad-A player?
  • Gordon Massa
  • Sam Mele
  • Ed Mierkowicz: A name that sounds like he should have been a mechanic on the Andy Griffith show.
  • Carl Miles
  • Don Minnick
  • Steve Nagy
  • Morris Nettles: No relation
  • Russ Nixon
  • Luis Olmo: In baseball random happens. Olmo tripled 13 times in 1945 to lead the NL—more than half his 25 career three-baggers.
  • John Orsino
  • Lee Pfund
  • Ruben Quevedo: A real lifesaver in baseball Scrabble.
  • Robert Ramsay
  • Johnny Rutherford
  • Bob Sadowski
  • Charlie Sands
  • Joe Schaffernoth
  • Roy Sievers: Sievers won the Rookie of the Year in 1949. He suffered some shoulder and arm injuries the next several years. He slumped terribly in 1950 as a 23 year old, and according to the man, himself, the organization tried to fiddle with his swing. It didn’t work. The Brownies jerked him around for another three years before dealing him to Washington. He was 27. Through age 34, all he did was make four All-Star teams, receive MVP votes six times, finishing as high as third, and lead the AL in homers in 1957 with 42, despite playing his home games in cavernous Griffith Stadium. Stupidly, the team made him a left fielder. He was OK at first but poor in the pastures, and the long distances in DC exposed him. He later played in Comiskey Park, another chamber of horrors for power hitters. One wonders how many dingers he’d have hit playing in Wrigley Field or Fenway Park. Or, for that matter, for a team that knew what to do with him in his early 20s.
  • Daryl Spencer: Couldn’t hit. Average runner. Kinda spotty glove. But could fake it well enough in the middle infield to be an average big leaguer…until he couldn’t, which took about 4000 PA. A fairly similar player in all these regards to Billy Martin
  • Dick Star: There used to be a lot of Dicks in the majors. Now, for reasons that should be obvious there aren’t. This guy should have gone by Rich.
  • Mike Strahler
  • Walt Streuli
  • Yordano Ventura: Another very sad and untimely death. Most deaths are untimely since in general we don’t want folks to die. With the exception of a few truly awful souls, whose deaths are untimely because we wished they’d gone sooner. Anyway, a la Jose Fernandez above, we can’t speak much to what baseball’s future loses in Ventura’s absence. He threw a mere 548 innings. Mostly they were good innings, and he finished with a 106 ERA+ and 7.2 WAR. After his age-25 season, he had a nice set of comps that included Jack Morris, Gio Gonzalez, Ernie Broglio, Darryl Kile (spookily), Joe Sparma, Wade Miller, Black Jack McDowell, Roy Halladay, and Mike Torrez. All of these guys were quality pitchers (Gonzalez, of course, is still at it). If an arc between Wade Miller and Roy Halladay describes his potential MLB career, then any fan would want to see it through.
  • Ken Wright
  • Jose Zardon

And that’s our baseball memorial roll since last Memorial Day. There’s lots more to say about any or all of these guys. Please add your thoughts in the comments.

HoME Standings III: finally, fully updated

We’re finally into the top ten in the HoME Standings. If your favorite team isn’t on the list below, check back on our first two posts You’ll be shocked, SHOCKED, to learn who our top contestant is, but there’s a lot going on underneath them, and if your favorite nine remains, cheer up, most of these clubs have some very interesting prospects for advancement.


TEAM                       YEARS    HoMERS /YEAR
10 Cleveland Indians     1901–2017  11.11   0.10
 9 Oakland Athletics     1901–2017  11.40   0.10
 8 Detroit Tigers        1901–2017  13.15   0.12
 7 Boston Red Sox        1901–2017  13.37   0.12
 6 St. Louis Cardinals   1882–2017  13.92   0.11
 5 Atlanta Braves        1876-2017  15.45   0.11
 4 Chicago Cubs          1876–2017  17.91   0.13
 3 San Francisco Giants  1883–2017  18.50   0.14
 2 Los Angeles Dodgers   1884–2017  19.63   0.15
 1 New York Yankees      1903–2017  22.16   0.21
  • Cleveland Indians
    HoMErs: Bob Feller (100%), Lou Boudreau (96%), Stan Coveleski (81%), Joe Sewell (79%), Nap Lajoie (64%), Elmer Flick (63%), Kenny Lofton (62%), Tris Speaker (55%), Joe Jackson (50%), Wes Ferrell (50%), Early Wynn (50%), Manny Ramirez (42%), Buddy Bell (41%), Al Lopez (38%), Joe Gordon (36%), Luis Tiant (34%), Gaylord Perry (21%), Roberto Alomar (20%), Denis Eckersley (19%), Graig Nettles (19%), Orel Hershiser (18%), Bert Blyleven (15%), Chuck Finley (14%), Eddie Murray (10%), Bobby Bonds (8%), Phil Niekro (7%), Cy Young (7%), Sam Rice (4%), Frank Robinson (2%), Steve Carlton (2%), Keith Hernandez (2%), Hal Newhouser (2%), Jeff Kent (1%), Dave Winfield (1%)
  • Retired: Jim Thome (115), Dwight Gooden (99), George Uhle (97), Ralph Kiner (96), Jason Giambi (95), Larry Doby (95), Cliff Lee (95), Mark Langston (95)
  • Active: C.C. Sabathia (104), Bartolo Colon (86), Victor Martinez (74), Corey Kluber (55), Terry Francona

The Tribe has done a nice job of developing and collecting HoME talent…and a lousy job of timing many of those acquisitions. But Thome and Sabathia should provide about 1 HoME career between them. As we mentioned last time, Larry Doby could also contribute 80% of a career if we do the Negro Leagues and elect him. Call it 1.9 or so careers. Tack on maybe a third of Tito’s tenure, and there’s a lot in the till. Definitely enough to claim 9th place, maybe enough to reach 8th. It’s probably too late for Michael Brantley to build enough of a case to make the HoME, but Corey Kluber and Francisco Lindor are well on their way, and Carlos Carrasco and Danny Salazar have enough talent that if one of them goes on the Randy Johnson career path, they could be a contender. I wouldn’t be the house on that, though.

Oakland Athletics

  • HoMErs: Connie Mack (96%), Eddie Plank (86%), Bob Johnson (79%), Mickey Cochrane (78%), Sal Bando (73%), Mark McGwire (71%), Rube Waddell (63%), Lefty Grove (60%), Al Simmons (59%), Home Run Baker (58%), Rickey Henderson (56%), Jimmie Foxx (54%), Reggie Jackson (48%), Eddie Collins (38%), Tony Phillips (38%), Wally Schang (30%), Tony La Russa (29%), Denis Eckersley (18%), Dick Williams (16%), Nap Lajoie (15%), Kevin Appier (11%), Billy Williams (10%), Frank Thomas (8%), Ty Cobb (7%), Jimmy Collins (7%), Goose Gossage (5%), Mike Piazza (4%), Joe Morgan (4%), Don Sutton (4%), Willie Randolph (4%), Zack Wheat (3%), Dick Allen (3%), Tris Speaker (2%), Tim Raines (1%), Elmer Flick (1%), Joe Jackson (1%), Stan Coveleski (1%), Willie McCovey (+0%)
  • Retired: Eddie Rommel (106), Tim Hudson (102), Gene Tenace (102), Ron Cey (97), Enos Slaughter (96), Jason Giambi (95), Billy Martin
  • Active: Ben Zobrist (90), Bartolo Colon (86), Josh Donaldson (85), Matt Holliday (82), Carlos Gonzalez (62), Billy Beane

Those Swingin’ A’s are about to slide outside the top ten. We talked about the surging Phils the last time out, and the Indians just above, and they will sweep away the Athletics who have very little to come back at them with. About 40% of Hudson, Billy Bean, and tiny bits of some others who might or might not pan out. It could be 1.0 to 1.5 careers. Not enough to catch the next team, not enough to drown out the war drumming of the Indians, maybe just enough to Phight the Phils phor now.

Detroit Tigers

  • HoMErs: Bill Freehan (100%), Charlie Gehringer (100%), Al Kaline (100%), Alan Trammell (100%), Lou Whitaker (100%), Hal Newhouser (98%), Harry Heilmann (94%), Ty Cob (93%), Hank Greenberg (92%), Bobby Veach (90%), Sam Crawford (84%), Sparky Anderson (64%), Jim Bunning (505), Tony Phillips (36%), Darrell Evans (26%), Ivan Rodriguez (25%), Goose Goslin (23%), Mickey Cochrane (22%), Gary Sheffield (10%), Al Simmons (7%), Eddie Mathews (2%), Wally Schang (1%)
  • Retired: Hughie Jennings (102), Charlie Keller (101), Chet Lemon (99), George Uhle (97), Dizzy Trout (95), Larry Doby (95)
  • Active: Miguel Cabrera (115), Justin Verlander (101), Ian Kinsler (99), Max Scherzer (98), Curtis Granderson (86), David Price (75), Victor Martinez (74), Jordan Zimmerman (55)

I’m pretty sanguine about the chances of Cabrera, Verlander, Kinsler, and Scherzer together, they’d add about 2.4 careers to the Bengals’ total. That’s certain to push the team at least one or two notches upward, and maybe more. After that, however, Price wasn’t around that long and his future isn’t certain given his current injury. Jordan Zimmerman would need to turn in a great second act, and none of the other active players looks like they will step up.

Boston Red Sox

  • HoMErs: Bobby Doerr (100%), Ted Williams (100%), Carl Yastrzemski (100%), Dwight Evans (97%), Harry Hooper (71%), Wade Boggs (68%), Roger Clemens (56%), Reggie Smith (53%), Joe Cronin (52%), Luis Tiant (51%), Pedro Martinez (48%), Manny Ramirez (48%), Carlton Fisk (44%), Denis Eckersley (42%), Jimmie Foxx (41%), Lefty Grove (40%), Tris Speaker (38%), Cy Young (35%), Wes Ferrell (33%), Jimmy Collins (27%), Red Ruffing (25%), Curt Schilling (21%), Wally Schang (18%), Dick Williams (16%), Bob Johnson (15%), Bret Saberhagen (13%), Babe Ruth (13%), Frank Chance (9%), Fergie Jenkins (9%), Bobby Veach (8%), Andre Dawson (7%), Jesse Burkett (7%), David Cone (5%), Lou Boudreau (4%), Tom Seaver (2%), Juan Marichal (2%), Rickey Henderson (2%), Al Simmons (1%), John Smoltz (1%)
  • Retired: John Olerud (99), Dizzy Trout (95)
  • Active: Adrian Beltre (115), Dustin Pedroia (87), Chris Sale (86), Bartolo Colon (86), Adrian Gonzalez (85), Jon Lester (84), Hanley Ramirez (77), David Price (75), Victor Martinez (74), John Lackey (72), Theo Epstein, Terry Francona, John Henry

The Sox have been great in the Twenty-First Century, though often featuring a roster full of talented players. Among the players above, what they seem likely to end up with is about 10% of Beltre’s career, at least 80% of Pedroia’s career, at least 20% of Sale’s career, if he doesn’t break down, about 60% of Lester’s tenure, half of Theo, and a third of Tito 2.5 careers. That’s a lot! If Miller and I get sentimental, then maybe David Ortiz has a shot. At this point he’s more appropriate for the Hall of Fame rather than the Hall of Miller and Eric. Like Detroit, if things bounce right for them, the Sox could barge into the top five. In the longer term, Mookie Betts, Xander Bogaerts, and, perhaps, Andrew Benintendi can give them additional fuel to continue rising in the standings.

St. Louis Cardinals

  • HoMErs: Sam Breadon (100%), Bob Gibson (100%), Stan Musial (100%), Ken Boyer (85%), Ozzie Smith (75%), Rogers Hornsby (71%), Ted Simmons (67%), Whitey Herzog (64%), Branch Rickey (61%), Frankie Frisch (56%), Billy Southworth (55%), Keith Hernandez (55%), Jim Edmonds (55%), Tony La Russa (51%), Johnny Mize (49%), Miller Huggins (30%), Mark McGwire (29%), Roger Bresnahan (25%), Steve Carlton (24%), Jesse Burkett (20%), Bobby Wallace (10%), Roger Connor (17%), Reggie Smith (17%), Joe Torre (16%), Bob Howsam (16%), Jose Cruz (16%), Pete Alexander (16%), Charlie Comiskey (15%), Jack Glasscock (11%), Cy Young (9%), Kid Nichols (8%), Dick Allen (7%), Mordecai Brown (7%), Larry Walker (7%), Bill McKechnie (6%), Dazzy Vance (5%), Vic Willis (5%), Willie Davis (4%), Denis Eckersley (3%), Bobby Bonds (3%), Chuck Finley (3%), Jimmy Sheckard (2%), Pud Galvin (2%), Clark Griffith (1%), John Smoltz (1%)
  • Retired: Bob Caruthers (116), Scott Rolen (115), Cupid Childs (106), Dizzy Dean (106), Pete Browning (104), George Gore (102), Gene Tenace (102), Will Clark (101), Cesar Cedeño (98), Jake Beckley (97), Ted Breitenstein (96), Tony Mullane (96), Enos Slaughter (96), Babe Adams (95), Lance Berkman (95), Joe Medwick (95)
  • Active: Albert Pujols (163), Carlos Beltran (115), Adam Wainwright (85), Matt Holliday (82), Yadier Molina (76), John Lackey (72), John Mozeliak

If everything goes the Cards’ way, they could make a big jump. That would mean we elected Rolen, Slaughter, Pujols, Beltran, Molina, and Wainwright, putting about 3.75 Cards careers into the HoME. Or we might only end up with Rolen, Pujols, and Beltran, which would be about 1.2 careers. When you look at how these standings are bunched, that’s a very large difference. Perhaps enough to swing 6th place to someone else.

Atlanta Braves    

  • HoMErs: John Smoltz (98%), Warren Spahn (96%), Eddie Mathews (94%), Hank Aaron (94%), Kid Nichols (90%), Bobby Cox (86%), Phil Niekro (85%), Frank Selee (77%), Tom Glavine (77%), Vic Willis (65%), John Schuerholz (63%), Greg Maddux (49%), John Clarkson (47%), Billy Southworth (45%), Billy Hamilton (42%), Bill McKechnie (34%), Darrell Evans (33%), Old Hoss Radbourn (32%), George Wright (32%), King Kelly (30%), Charlie Bennett (30%), Jimmy Collins (25%), Casey Stengel (23%), Dave Bancroft (23%), Harry Wright (21%), George Sisler (19%), Sherry Magee (17%), Jim O’Rourke (14%), Ross Barnes (12%), Gary Sheffield (11%), Joe Torre (11%), Bill Dahlen (8%), Dan Brouthers (7%), Jimmy Wynn (7%), Paul Waner (7%), Rogers Hornsby (7%), Kenny Lofton (6%), Ted Simmons (5%), Paul Hines (4%), Deacon White (4%), Al Simmons (4%), Billy Herman (3%), Gaylord Perry (3%), Graig Nettles (2%), Cy Young (1%), Babe Ruth (1%), Ed Walsh (1%), Wes Ferrell (1%), Bucky Walters (+0%)
  • Retired: Chipper Jones (120), Andruw Jones (115), Tim Hudson (102), Charlie Buffinton (97), Harry Stovey (100), Wally Berger (97), Enos Slaughter (96), Hardy Richardson (95)
  • Active: Bartolo Colon (86), Brian McCann (72), Jason Heyward (69)

Jones, Jones, and Hudson would give the Bravos another 2.3 careers. And they need every one because it’ll be a long time before anyone else is electable. Those are the last of the 1990s Braves and most of the last of the 2000s Braves that made the playoffs for nearly a decade. Jason Heyward? Maybe Freddie Freeman? Could Julio Tehran take a step up and stay there a long while? It won’t be enough to catch the Cubbies, it should be enough to hold off the Cards’s best case scenario.

Chicago Cubs

  • HoMErs: Ernie Banks (100%), William Hulbert (100%), Ryne Sandberg (100%), Al Spalding (100%), Gabby Hartnett (98%), Ron Santo (96%), Billy Williams (90%), Cap Anson (89%), Joe Tinker (86%), Sammy Sosa (80%), Frank Chance (73%), Mordecai Brown (72%), Billy Herman (71%), Rick Reuschel (65%), Fergie Jenkins (59%), Jimmy Sheckard (48%), King Kelly (48%), Bill Dahlen (44%), Greg Maddux (41%), Greg Maddux (41%), John Clarkson (37%), Pete Alexander (37%), Andre Dawson (33%), Leo Durocher (28%), Frank Selee (23%), Joe McCarthy (22%), Roger Bresnahan (19%), Ross Barnes (18%), Tommy Leach (17%), Denis Eckersley (16%), Rogers Hornsby (14%), Clark Griffith (14%), Richie Ashburn (11%), Rube Waddell (9%), Rafael Palmeiro (8%), Paul Hines (8%), Deacon White (4%), Jim Edmonds (4%), Goose Gossage (3%), Jimmie Foxx (3%), Kenny Lofton (3%), Bobby Bonds (2%), Robin Roberts (1%)
  • Retired: Dizzy Dean (106), Ned Williamson (104), George Gore (102), Ron Cey (97), Ralph Kiner (96), Jim Sundberg (96)
  • Active: Ben Zobrist (90), Jon Lester (84), John Lackey (72), Jason Heyward (69), Anthony Rizzo (55), Jake Arrieta (53), Theo Epstein, Joe Maddon

What makes the Cubs’ a threat to go dynasty on the league is also what makes their near term HoME outlook a little bleak. The earliest they might elect a player that we haven’t already passed over is maybe eight to ten years from now. That’s when Ben Zobrist comes due. He might yet assemble a strong enough case, or he might just fall short. Jon Lester will arrive several years after that, and the team should get a nice chunk of his career. If Jason Heyward learns to hit again, his turn would be another for or more years thereafter. But he’s a big question mark. After that, you’re waiting for Theo or Maddon to retire, though Maddon will have a tougher climb if he doesn’t win another title. At that point it’s probably also Rizzo’s time. He’s been awfully good and very durable, and if we’ve seen his best, he’ll have to go the Eddie Murray route and be very good for very long. Then it’ll be Kris Bryant’s turn. He’s played a total of 344 games, so I’m not excited to start calling him a HoMEr yet. His BBREF comps have some danger signs: Danny Tartabull, Ralph Kiner, Carlos Gonzalez, Rocky Colavito, Fernando Tatis, Tom Tresh. Let’s not start casting the bronze quite yet. There’s a lot of reason for optimism here, and there’s not much we can safely predict yet.

San Francisco Giants  

  • HoMErs: Carl Hubbell (100%), Mel Ott (100%), Bill Terry (100%), Christy Mathewson (+99%), Juan Marichal (98%), Willie Mays (96%), Amos Rusie (93%), John McGraw (93%), Willie McCovey (88%), Art Fletcher (86%), Barry Bonds (66%), Joe McGinnity (61%), Monte Ward (61%), Bobby Bonds (57%), Roger Connor (56%), Buck Ewing (55%), George Davis (47%), Tim Keefe (44%), Frankie Frisch (44%), Roger Bresnahan (43%), Gaylord Perry (43%), Darrell Evans (41%), Jeff Kent (41%), Jim O’Rourke (39%), Johnny Mize (38%), Leo Durocher (31%), Dave Bancroft (30%), Bill Dahlen (22%), Rick Reuschel (16%), Jack Glasscock (13%), Joe Morgan (8%), Rogers Hornsby (7%), Orel Hershiser (7%), Reggie Smith (5%), Jesse Burkett (5%), Gary Carter (3%), Goose Gossage (2%), Randy Johnson (2%), Duke Snider (2%), Gabby Hartnett (2%), Kenny Lofton (2%), Warren Spahn (1%), King Kelly (1%), Willie Keeler (%), Steve Carlton 91%), Dan Brouthers (0%)
  • Retired: George Gore (102), Will Clark (101), Heinie Groh (101), Jake Beckley (97), Wally Berger (97), George Uhle (97), Joe Medwick (95), Hardy Richardson (95)
  • Active: Carlos Beltran (115), Buster Posey (89), Madison Bumgarner (72), Matt Cain (71), Johnny Cueto (69), Bruce Bochy, Dusty Baker, Brian Sabean

The Giants led the pack for many electoral years until our number one club wrested the top spot away about two-thirds through the journey. At this point, a chunk of Heinie Groh, a sliver of Beltran, probably most of Posey, and that’s the more bankable stuff. MadBum and Cueto are very much building their legend, and in the backlog, no one else is screaming elect-me to us at this time. So the Giants will need to turn to off-the-field honorees. Bochy is a slam-dunk and worth about two-thirds of a career. Sabean’s probably also a slam dunk, and he appears to be a lifer at PacBell/AT&T/whatever it’s called now. Dusty Baker ought to win the big one before any gets excited over his prospects. Sans the management team the Giants over the long term are likely to lose some ground to the pack whether or not they are passed. Their leadership is their saving grace.

Los Angeles Dodgers    

  • HoMErs: Walter Alston (100%), Roy Campanella (100%), Al Campanis (100%), Don Drysdale (100%), Sandy Koufax (100%), Walter O’Malley (100%), Pee Wee Reese (100%), Jackie Robinson (100%), Zack Wheat (97%), Duke Snider (93%), Dazzy Vance (93%), Willie Davis (82%), Don Sutton (72%), Orel Hershiser (69%), Buzzie Bavasi (60%), Larry MacPhail (45%), Jimmy Sheckard (41%), Ned Hanlon (40%), Mike Piazza (39%), Leo Durocher (35%), Willie Keeler (27%), Bill Dahlen (27%), Kevin Brown (26%), Reggie Smith (26%), Billy Herman 925%), Jeff Kent (23%), Gary Sheffield (21%), Arky Vaughan (20%), Branch Rickey (20%), Eddie Murray (15%), Jimmy Wynn (15%), Monte Ward (15%), Dan Brouthers (13%), Davey Johnson (13%), Casey Stengel (12%), Dave Bancroft (12%), Joe Torre (10%), Max Carey (10%), Manny Ramirez (9%), Dick Allen (9%), Willie Randolph (8%), Kenny Lofton (6%), Paul Waner (4%), Pedro Martinez (4%), Frank Robinson (3%), Ken Boyer (3%), Gary Carter (3%), Greg Maddux (2%), Jim Bunning (2%), Rickey Henderson (1%), Juan Marichal (+0%), Wes Ferrell (+0%)
  • Retired: Bob Caruthers (116), Andruw Jones (115), Jim Thome (115), Pete Browning (104), Jim McCormick (103), Hughie Jennings (102), Nap Rucker (102), Harry Stovey (100), Mike Griffin (99), Cesar Cedeño (98), Ron Cey (97), Wilbur Cooper (97), Bobby Abreu (95), Joe Medwick (95)
  • Active: Clayton Kershaw (119), Adrian Beltre (115), Zack Grienke (107), Chase Utley (104), Russell Martin (93), Adrian Gonzalez (85), Hanley Ramirez (77)

We can’t realistically predict how long a player will stay with his team. Even if he signs a big, long contract, trades, buy-outs, and opt-outs happen. So I can really only give about 60% of Clayton Kershaw to the Dodgers. Adrian Beltre is worth about 40% of a career to the team. Grienke about a quarter of a career. Chase Utley about 15%. If Russell Martin should rebound enough to just ease over the line, then there’s probably another 40%. Among retirees, Andruw Jones is three points, Jim Thome’s worth 0% (just 17 PAs). En toto that’s about 1.8 careers, if things work out well. The Dodgers need 2.5 careers just to reach where the Yanks are right now. It’s absolutely possible to squint and see Corey Seager and Cody Bellinger and Julio Urias all coming through. But I don’t trust my squinty eyes that much.

New York Yankees      

  • HoMErs: Ed Barrow (100%), Bill Dickey (100%), Joe DiMaggio (100%), Whitey Ford (100%), Lou Gehrig (100%), Mickey Mantle (100%), Thurman Munson (100%), Jacob Ruppert (100%), Roy White (100%), Yogi Berra (100%), Babe Ruth (87%), Willie Randolph (79%), Red Ruffing (72%), Miller Huggins (70%), George Weiss (68%), Joe McCarthy (67%), Joe Gordon (64%), Graig Nettles (61%), Casey Stengel (49%), Joe Torre (45%), Mike Mussina (44%), Home Run Baker (42%), Dave Winfield (51%), Willie Keeler (39%), Urban Shocker (35%), David Cone (32%), Wally Schang (30%), Goose Gossage (28%), Larry MacPhail (27%), Wade Boggs (25%), Reggie Jackson (24%), Roger Clemens (23%), Joe Sewell (21%), Rickey Henderson (20%), Frank Chance (18%), Gary Sheffield (14%), Johnny Mize (13%), Randy Johnson (10%), Luis Tiant (10%), Clark Griffith (9%), Tim Raines (9%), Phil Niekro (8%), Bobby Bonds (8%), Kevin Brown (7%), Kenny Lofton (3%), Wes Ferrell (2%), Stan Coveleski (2%), Rick Reuschel (2%), Bobby Veach (2%), Jimmy Wynn (1%), Dazzy Vance (1%), Gaylord Perry (1%), Jose Cruz (1%), Ivan Rodriguez (1%), Paul Waner (+0%)
  • Retired: Alex Rodriguez (172), Andruw Jones (115), Andy Pettitte (102), Charlie Keller (101), Derek Jeter (100), Dwight Gooden (99), Noodles Hahn (99), John Olerud (99), Ron Guidry (98), George Uhle (97), Bernie Williams (97), Enos Slaughter (96), Bobby Abreu (95), Lance Berkman (95), Jason Giambi (95), Mariano Rivera
  • Active: Robinson Cano (120) Carlos Beltran (115), CC Sabathia (104), Ichiro (102), Russell Martin (93), Bartolo Colon (86), Curtis Granderson (86), Matt Holliday (82), Brian McCann (72), Brian Cashman, Joe Girardi

No doubt that no one is shocked to see Emperor Palpatine’s favorite team leading the pack. They will get 3.33 to 3.5 careers just out of the retirees. Establishing a long dynasty and staying competitive does that. Cano, Beltran, Sabathia, Ichiro together will add another 1.25 to 1.5 careers. So the New York Vaders are tacking on 5 HoMErs in short order. Toss Cashman and Girardi on the heap, and that’s for reals like 7 careers’ worth of Yankees. Hate or hate ‘em, they get the job done.

So that’s the state of play for now. Of course, this is all speculation and prediction. No one knows whether Clayton Kershaw will suddenly demand a trade to the Rays, or whether  Derek Jeter will buy the Marlins and put himself at shortstop, or whether Jason Hayward will rediscover his stroke or discover he’s had a stroke. It’s all up in the air. These are just some best guesses at what the future holds. And as a certain philosopher once said: “It’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future.”

Home Standings Part II: Finally, fully updated

On Monday, we began our look at the HoME team cap standings with defunct franchises as well as the bottom third of the current league. Some of those expansion squads and the ones we’ll talk about in a moment actually have a chance to climb into the Ring of Sixteen. None has yet, but the day may be coming soon, ya know. Once again, we’ll look at each team’s future HoME outlook by examining their current HoMErs, retired players with a 95 or higher CHEWS+, and active players with a good shot (CHEWS+ through the 2016 season).


TEAM                        YEARS    HoMERS /YEAR
20 Kansas City Royals     1969–2017   3.18   0.08
19 LA Angels of Anaheim   1961–2017   3.92   0.08
18 Houston Astros         1962–2017   4.85   0.10
17 New York Mets          1962–2017   4.94   0.10
16 Minnesota Twins        1901–2017   6.07   0.06
15 Cincinnati Reds        1882-2017   9.20   0.07
14 Pittsburgh Pirates     1882–2017   9.83   0.08
13 Philadelphia Phillies  1883–2017  10.02   0.08
12 Baltimore Orioles      1901–2017  10.05   0.09
11 Chicago White Sox      1901–2017  10.50   0.10

Kansas City Royals

  • HoMErs: George Brett (100%), Kevin Appier (70%), Bret Saberhagen (65%), John Schuerholz (37%), Whitey Herzog (30%), David Cone (15%), Gaylord Perry (2%)
  • Retired: Jim Sundberg (95)
  • Active: Carlos Beltran (115), Zack Grienke (107), Ben Zobrist (90), Jose Bautista (82), Alex Gordon (69), Johnny Cueto (69)

Isn’t it kinda weird that George Brett is the only KC position player to make the HoME? While Beltran (35% of a career) and Grienke (40%) will give the R’s a nice boost, no one else is an odds-on favorite quite yet. Zobrist is inching closer, but in his mid-30s, his game could collapse at any moment. Alex Gordon’s run at immortality has stalled thanks to injuries. Cueto is still very much making his case, but he spent only about two months in Royal blue. Jose Bautista spent less time than even that. So looks the team will at best tread HoME water for some time to come, and at worst will be forced to dip their crowns as other clubs pass them by. Unless, that is, Sal Perez takes a step forward as a hitter in his late 20s and deep into his 30s.

Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim

  • HoMErs: Chuck Finley (84%), Bobby Grich (59%), Nolan Ryan (41%), Jim Edmonds (37%), Rod Carew (34%), Buzzie Bavasi (24%), Reggie Jackson (24%), Bobby Bonds (14%), Tony Phillips (12%), Dick Williams (11%), Kevin Appier (11%), Bert Blyleven (10%), Frank Robinson (10%), Dave Winfield (9%), Don Sutton (8%), Eddie Murray (1%), Rickey Henderson (1%), Luis Tiant (1%), Willie Davis (1%), Whitey Herzog (+0%).
  • Retired: Vlad Guerrero (101), Bobby Abreu (95), Mark Langston (95), Harry Dalton
  • Active: Albert Pujols (165), Mike Trout (118), Zack Grienke (107), Bartolo Colon (86), John Lackey (72), Joe Maddon

It’s not a bad outlook for the Angels. They’ve got enough to stay ahead of the Royals and might have enough cushion to keep up with the hard-charging teams behind that. On the other hand, in the longer term, the team has little in the minor league system and may be due for a rebuild, so you Halo Hombres might be facing a long drought after Mike Trout. Who by the way, you might notice already has a compelling case for the HoME based on his performance through 2016. He’s on a 10-WAR pace again this year.

Houson Astros

  • HoMErs: Jeff Bagwell (100%), Craig Biggio (100%), Jose Cruz (83%), Jimmy Wynn (75%), Joe Morgan (40%), Nolan Ryan (34%), Jeff Kent (12%), Roger Clemens (11%), Don Sutton (7%), Leo Durocher (5%), Eddie Mathews (4%), Ivan Rodriguez (3%), Robin Roberts (3%), Buddy Bell (3%), Curt Schilling (3%), Randy Johnson (2%), Kenny Lofton (1%)
  • Retired: Andy Pettitte (102), Roy Oswalt (101), Cesar Cedeño (98), Lance Berkman (95), Bobby Abreu (95)
  • Active: Carlos Beltran (115), Brian McCann (72)

If we elect Oswalt, then the Astros have enough on hand to rocket past the lowest member in the Ring of Sixteen (about 1.2 careers). Even if not, they have a wide launch window. Unlike the Angels and Royals, the Stros have youngsters with the right stuff to take off into stardom. Carlos Correa, Dallas Keuchel, Jose Altuve, and maybe even George Springer have HoME liftoff potential. Put this team in the watch bucket. And they are awfully close to passing…

New York Mets

  • HoMErs: Tom Seaver (63%), Mike Piazza (51%), Keith Hernandez (43%), Davey Johnson (41%), David Cone (41%), George Weiss (32%), Gary Carter (32%), Tom Glavine (23%), Jeff Kent (21%), Bret Saberhagen (20%), Pedro Martinez (18%), Joe Torre (16%), Casey Stengel (15%), Eddie Murray (10%), Nolan Ryan (10%), Roberto Alomar (9%), Ken Boyer (9%), Kevin Appier (8%), Orel Hershiser (6%), Duke Snider (5%), Rickey Henderson (5%), Richie Ashburn (5%), Willie Mays (4%), Willie Randolph (4%), Gary Sheffield (3%), Warren Spahn (3%), Tony Phillips (3%), Yogi Berra (+0%)
  • Retired: Johan Santaña (110), John Olerud (99), Dwight Gooden (99), Bobby Abreu (95), Frank Cashen
  • Active: Carlos Beltran (115), David Wright (101), Curtis Granderson (86), Bartolo Colon (86), Sandy Alderson

The Mets could flex some serious HoME muscle. Santaña certainly has my eye, Beltran’s basically a given, and Wright is right on my borderline even if he never plays again. Add them up, and they’d be worth a minimum of a player and a half, maybe almost two. That’s enough to bust into the ring of sixteen. There’s also considerable young talent on the current roster. Michael Conforto is the only young hitter with potential for special things (if the team would quite jerking him around), but we already know that several of their pitchers have Hall kind of talent. But can they convert to a HoME career? Noah Syndergaard, of course. Who knows whether Matt Harvey can recapture his form, but if so, he’s got a shot. Jacob DeGrom has been great when he’s been healthy. I won’t tell you that all or most of these guys will end up near the HoME, but one might. That is if Mr. Met will leave Thor alone….

The Ring of Sixteen: The next big step for our expansion clubs is to slide into the sixteenth spot. Our next entrant has the lowest total of HoME careers among any of the teams thought of as the original AL/NL teams of the early two-league era. Consider these franchises have 60 to 100 years on their younger competitors, it’s impressive that any latter-day teams could make a run at entering the Ring of Sixteen, and it’s, in a darker way, impressive that one of the sixteen has been this unbelievably bad at collecting and locking down great players.

Minnesota Twins

  • HoMErs: Walter Johnson (100%), Sam Rice (96%), Clark Griffith (70%), Rod Carew (66%), Goose Goslin (59%), Bert Blyleven (51%), Joe Cronin (47%), Early Wynn (28%), Stan Coveleski (17%), Paul Molitor (15%), Wes Ferrell (14%), Al Simmons (10%), Ed Delahanty (8%), Dave Winfield (7%), Bob Johnson (6%), Tris Speaker (5%), Graig Nettles (3%), Luis Tiant (3%), Steve Carlton (1%), Bobby Veach (1%), George Sisler (1%)
  • Retired: Jim Thome (115), Johan Santaña (110)
  • Active: Joe Mauer (109), Andy MacPhail

Yah know, that’s a heck of a pickle they got themselves into. They’ve got it worse than any other olde tyme team. How come our team is goinabe the first one of the original-16 that’s bein’ passed by some lousy expansion team? That Miguel Sano, though, he’s pretty darned important. He could be a true star and can make a HoME-run! That’ll help our Twinkies keep those Mets and Astros at bay. Well, it’s not like Brian Dozier’s going to keep it up forever after comin’ out of nowhere. And when Byron Buxton is hittin’, he looks like a walleye put into saltwater. And we haven’t had a half-decent pitcher come along since they got Radke and Santana. Well, Idaknow. things’ll get better, donchaknow.

Cincinnati Reds

  • HoMErs: Johnny Bench (100%), Barry Larkin (100%), Bid McPhee (100%), Bob Howsam (84%), Pete Rose (78%), Bucky Walters (75%), Frank Robinson (55%), Joe Morgan (44%), Bill McKechnie (38%), Sparky Anderson (36%), Ken Griffey, Jr. (35%), Larry MacPhail (27%), Tom Seaver (23%), Sam Crawford (16%), Buddy Bell (16%), Davey Johnson (15%), Buck Ewing (12%), Ned Hanlon (10%), Sherry Magee (10%), Charlie Comiskey (7%), Harry Heilmann (6%), Joe Tinker (6%), Mordecai Brown (6%), Clark Griffith (5%), Hoss Radbourn (5%), Tommy Leach (4%), Jimmy Sheckard (2%), Dazzy Vance (1%), Amos Rusie (1%), Jim Edmonds (+0%), Al Simmons (+0%), Christy Mathewson (+0%)
  • Retired: Scott Rolen (115), Pete Browning (104), Heinie Groh (101), Noodles Hahn (99), Cesar Cedeño (98), Jake Beckley (97), Wally Berger (97), Ted Breitenstein (96), Tony Mullane (96)
  • Active: Joey Votto (104), Johnny Cueto (69)

At least the Redlegs won’t get rolled by a team half their age like the Twins. However, they are one of only two other squads in the Ring of Sixteen with fewer than 10 total HoME careers. Obviously, that’s not good. The Reds, like the Twins, have often seemed downright provincial in their operations, perhaps contributing to their general lack of HoME-level players. There’s an additional consideration here that works in their favor. Should we get play-by-play data in for Edd Roush that improves his standing, he could become a more serious candidate. The same could be true for Joe Kelley, but we know that’s not coming for eons. Aside from that, Heinie Groh is the most likely old-timer on the list to make it. The current Reds offer little in terms of future stardom, have a couple back doors to make progress, and, overall, should get into the 10+ club relatively soon. Unlike, say, the Twins.

Pittsburgh Pirates

  • HoMErs: Joe Brown (100%), Roberto Clemente (100%), Max Carey (90%), Paul Waner (89%), Honus Wagner (87%), Arky Vaughan (80%), Barney Dreyfuss (76%), Tommy Leach (73%), Fred Clarke (65%), Pud Galvin (35%), Barry Bonds (34%), Vic Willis (29%), Bill McKechnie (19%), Rick Reuschel (17%), Bert Blyleven (14%), Branch Rickey (12%), Jack Glasscock (9%), Jim Bunning (9%), Hank Greenberg (8%), Rube Waddell (8%), Goose Gossage (7%), Ned Hanlon (5%), Kenny Lofton (4%), Connie Mack (4%), Deacon White (4%), Paul Hines (2%), Luis Tiant (2%), Joe Cronin (1%) Willie Randolph (1%), Billy Herman (1%), Dazzy Vance (+0%)
  • Retired: Pete Browning (104), Jim McCormick (103), Heinie Groh (101), Jake Beckley (97), Fred Dunlap (96), Ralph Kiner (96)
  • Active: Russell Martin (93), Andrew McCutchen (87), Jose Bautista (82)

Unless Andrew McCutchen rebounds, the Bucs stop here. Among retired players, only Groh has a real shot. Among the actives, we’ve already mentioned that Martin is in a doldrums in his mid-thirties, and we all know that McCutchen’s gone from MVP to swabbie. Gerrit Cole might help in the long term. Gregory Polanco doesn’t look like much of a hitter, and Sterling Marte just failed a pee test. As soon as Joey Votto is eligible for the HoME, the Reds will fly the flag of 14th placed. But, me hardees, that’s what happens when ye have two decades a losin’. Squawk! Two-decades a-losing’, two decades a losin’. Squawk!

Philadelphia Phillies

  • HoMErs: Mike Schmidt (100%), Ed Delahanty (85%), Richie Ashburn (84%), Robin Roberts (80%), Sherry Magee (74%), Steve Carlton (70%), Dick Allen (62%), Harry Wright (57%), Curt Schilling (51%), Pete Alexander (48%), Billy Hamilton (48%), Jim Bunning (40%), Elmer Flick (37%), Dave Bancroft (35%), Bucky Walters (25%), Nap Lajoie (21%), Pete Rose (20%), Art Fletcher (14%), Tim Keefe (12%), Pat Gillick (11%), Roger Connor (8%), Joe Morgan (4%), Kenny Lofton (4%), Dan Brouthers (3%), Kid Nichols (3%), Jimmie Fox (3%), Pedro Martinez (2%), Fergie Jenkins (+0%)
  • Retired: Roy Halladay (122), Scott Rolen (115), Jim Thome (115), Charlie Buffinton (107), Cupid Childs (106), Hughie Jennings (102), Roy Oswalt (101), Wally Berger (97), Cliff Lee (95), Bobby Abreu (95)
  • Active: Chase Utley (102), Cole Hamels (101), Terry Francona, Andy MacPhail

Sure seems like the Phils are going places over the next few HoME elections. Halladay, Thome, and Rolen will buy about 1.0 career. Chase Utley’s near the end of the string and a strong candidate. He’d add another 85% of a career. If Cole Hamels’ injury this year doesn’t wreck his career, he’s got a real nice shot at a plaque, fetching about two-thirds of a career. Tito is very, very close to being a slam dunk and worth about another third. Plus Childs, Jennings, and Oswalt represent small potential pickups as well, though none except maybe Oswalt, is nearly as sure as those mentioned above. At the MLB level now, the Phils have very little to offer as their best youngsters haven’t yet emerged from the minors. They are neck-and-neck with the O’s and not far behind the #12 and #11 teams either. In other words, things could get real interesting in the middle of the standings. Adding two-and-a-half careers would get the Phils inside the top and maybe even as high as #8.

Baltimore Orioles

  • HoMErs: Jim Palmer (100%), Cal Ripken Jr. (100%), Brooks Robinson (100%), Earl Weaver (100%), George Sisler (81%), Urban Shocker (65%), Bobby Wallace (64%), Eddie Murray (63%), Mike Mussina (56%), Bobby Grich (41%), Rafael Palmeiro (36%), Frank Robinson (30%), Wally Schang (20%), Jesse Burkett (19%), Goose Goslin (18%), Rube Waddell (18%), Roberto Alomar (18%), Robin Roberts (16%), Davey Johnson (13%), Pat Gillick (11%), Eddie Plank (8%), Branch Rickey (7%), Kevin Brown (5%), Reggie Jackson (5%), Sammy Sosa (4%) Dwight Evans (3%), Curt Schilling (2%), Tim Raines (+0%)
  • Retired: Jim Thome (115), Dizzy Dean (106), Vlad Guerrero (101), Will Clark (101), Dizzy Trout (95), Frank Cashen
  • Active: Jose Bautista (82), Manny Machado (71), Andy MacPhail, Buck Showalter

Another team where a long losing skid cost them a shot at a higher ranking. Thome’s tenure wasn’t long enough to make a difference, Dean’s was one game. Guerrero’s one season. Really, it’s Machado who can make the most difference. Whether Dylan Bundy or Kevin Gausman can be healthy or productive enough to join Manny, only time can tell. Either way, however, this team looks like its wings have been clipped, and it will a minimum of two ranks in the standings over the next couple decades.

Chicago White Sox

  • HoMErs: Luke Appling (100%), Red Faber (100%), Ted Lyons (100%), Ed Walsh (99%), Frank Thomas (85%), Charlie Comiskey (75%), Al Lopez (62%), Eddie Collins, (62%), Carlton Fisk (56%), Shoeless Joe Jackson (49%), George Davis (34%), Goose Gossage (34%), Harry Hooper (29%), Tim Raines (28%), Early Wynn (22%), Tony La Russa (20%), Dick Allen (19%), Al Simmons (19%), Tom Seaver (12%), Sammy Sosa (10%), Tony Phillips (10%), Ron Santo (4%), Kenny Lofton (4%), Roberto Alomar (3%), Clark Griffith (3%), Ken Boyer (3%), Ken Griffey, Jr. (1%), Red Ruffing (1%), Bobby Bonds (1%), Steve Carlton (1%), Manny Ramirez (1%), Dave Stieb (1%)
  • Retired: Jim Thome (115), Mark Buehrle (98), Larry Doby (95)
  • Active: Chris Sale (86), Bartolo Colon (86), Jose Quintana (55)

Most of Mark Buehrle and maybe a quarter of Chris Sale can’t hurt. It’s a little early to count on Quintana yet, but he’s well worth watching. The Chisox do, however, have a means to pick up some help. Doby and Minnie Miñoso (93 CHEWS+) are both near the borderline at their positions, and both will benefit if we choose to elect Negro Leagues players. Doby only a smidgen, but for Minnie, it’s likely three-quarters or more of a career. That won’t buy the team a boost in the standings, but it could keep a team or two at bay.

That’s a wrap for the second tier of our HoME standings. Next time, we check out the top-ten teams. There’s a lot of jockeying there for position beneath the undisputed holder of first place.

The HoME standings: finally, fully updated

It’s been more than a year since we’ve updated you on how your favorite team has fared in the HoME standings. David Neft’s election catches us all the way up to the Hall in each of the three categories we’ve voted for: players, managers, and pioneer/executives.

In a moment, we’ll show you the agate type to find out which teams are the most HoMErific. First quick notes on what the table shows you.

  1. Franchises that moved include players from before and after the move (e.g.: The Orioles’s HoMEr count includes players from the St. Louis Browns)
  2. We calculate the number of HoMErs for each team by finding the percentage of each honoree’s career was spent with a given club, then summing it for all who appeared for them
  3. Hitters are calculated based on plate appearances, pitchers by batters faced, managers by games managed, and execs by years of service as applicable
  4. HoMErs per year is (b) above divided by the number of years the franchise has been in existence.

To begin with, and to pay them their due while getting them out of the way, here are the results for all defunct franchises who played for five or more seasons:

TEAM                      YEARS    HoMERS /YEAR
Cleveland Spiders       1887–1899   1.60   0.12
Providence Grays        1878–1885   1.51   0.19
Boston Red Stockings    1871–1875   1.44   0.29
Buffalo Bisons          1878–1885   1.32   0.19
Detroit Wolverines      1881–1888   1.06   0.13
Louisville Colonels     1882–1899   1.01   0.06
Baltimore Orioles       1882–1899   0.99   0.05
Cincinnati Reds         1876–1880   0.34   0.07
Cleveland Blues         1879–1884   0.27   0.05
New York Metropolitans  1883–1887   0.21   0.04
Washington Senators     1891–1899   0.12   0.01
Philadelphia Athletics  1871–1875   0.10   0.02

More on the Spiders, Grays, Red Stockings, and Bisons later. Speaking of the latter, I’m not sure if it’s Bisons or Bison, but we ain’t speaking no Queens English neither. Not surprisingly most of these are well known among Nineteenth Century squads for one reason or another.

The period of stability ushered in by the contraction of the NL and the rise of the AL gives the rest of the standings more comprehensibility. We’ll knock out the thirty franchises in descending tiers of ten. I’ll give a quick write up for each team, listing their current HoMErs with the percentage of career spent with the team; all retired, unenshrined players with at least 95 CHEWS+; and active players who we might reasonably project as strong candidates (with CHEWS+ figures through the end of 2016).

Today, we’ll cover the bottom ten, and we’ll follow on with two more articles this week to cap things off.


TEAM                      YEARS    HoMERS /YEAR
30 Tampa Bay Rays        1998–2017  0.08   0.01
29 Miami Marlins         1993–2017  0.45   0.03
28 Colorado Rockies      1993–2017  0.62   0.03
27 Arizona Diamondbacks  1998–2017  0.63   0.05
26 Seattle Mariners      1977–2017  2.48   0.07
25 Toronto Blue Jays     1977-2017  2.55   0.07
24 Milwaukee Brewers     1969–2017  2.62   0.06
23 Texas Rangers         1961–2017  2.94   0.06
22 Washington Nationals  1969–2017  3.03   0.07
21 San Diego Padres      1969–2017  3.13   0.07

As you surely would have guessed, the four most recent expansion franchises finish in the ultimate, penultimate, antepenultimate, and anteantepenultimate slots. And the rest of the 20s are occupied by the three previous rounds of expansion.

Tampa Bay Rays

  • HoMErs: Wade Boggs (8%), Manny Ramirez (0.2%)
  • Retired: Dwight Gooden (99)
  • Active:Evan Longoria (102), Ben Zobrist (90), David Price (75), Joe Maddon

Chuck Lamar, eat your heart out. Sixteen defunct franchises stand between the Rays and the Marlins, most of which clubs only existed a year or two. Longo’s a good bet to deliver at least 80% of a career, Zobrist could give them another 60%, and Price 40% more. Maddon could give them another 50% depending how long he stays in the dugout and how many more titles he wins. So at a max, we’re looking at 2.3 more HoMErs within the next 20 years, but after Longo, there’s a lot of ifs. Still, even Longo’s contribution will at least get the team in the vicinity of the famous old NL Baltimore Orioles. Overall, Mantamen fans, it’s going to be a long wait.

Miami Marlins

  • HoMErs: Gary Sheffield (22%), Kevin Brown (14%), Ivan Rodriguez (6%), Andre Dawson (3%), Tim Raines (1%), Mike Piazza (5 amazing games)
  • Retired:  Mark Buehrle (98)
  • Active: Miguel Cabrera (115), Ichiro (102), Hanley Ramirez (77), Giancarlo Stanton (69), Dave Dombrowski

The Fish aren’t swimming in would-be honorees, but a few members of their school have a decent near-term shot to make a HoME splash. Cabrera is a lock, and he’s a third of a career. Ichiro is similarly locked in and would deliver at least 17% of a career. Buehrle is a borderline candidate and would give them 6% of a career should we find him worthy. So the team’s sitting on about 60% a career, give or take. At the big-league level, if Giancarlo Stanton stays healthy and productive, he should provide at least 50% of a career. After that, however, the cupboard is being restocked, but who knows who will be doing the shopping. Christian Yelich or Marcel Ozuna could go nuts for a few years and help out. This is a place where the team misses Jose Fernandez. En toto, the Marlins could see be passed by their Sunshine State rivals somewhat soon and have relatively little opportunity to climb the ladder where they swim now.

Colorado Rockies

  • HoMErs:Larry Walker (62%), Bret Saberhagen (2%)
  • Retired:  Todd Helton (112), Roy Oswalt (101), Jason Giambi (95)
  • Active: Troy Tulowitzki (86), Matt Holiday (82), Carlos Gonzalez (64), Nolan Arenado (58)

If we elect Todd Helton, which wouldn’t shock us, an entire career goes into the Rox column, which would push them beyond the Spiders’ Web (more on that in a moment). The Rockies, however, face a structural challenge like no other team. Despite the presence of 2% of Roy Oswalt’s career (and he’s no certainty for election), the Purple Mountain Majestics have to rely on hitters for virtually all of their representation in the HoME because it’s not like we’ll be seeing a long-tenured Rockies pitcher getting in soon…perhaps ever. Longer term, however, counting on Tulo to stay both healthy and productive is, uh, not a good bet. Let’s say he’s a 40% chance from this point forward to end up with a HoME career, which I think is pretty generous. He’s likely to have spent about 65% of his career as a Rocky. Multiply those odds by that career percentage, and you’ve got about another quarter of a player. Arenado (born on my birthday!) is something of an unsung hero, and I love his chances, but there’s a long way to go.

Arizona Diamondbacks

  • HoMErs:Randy Johnson (39%), Curt Schilling (23%), Roberto Alomar (1%)
  • Retired:  n/a
  • Active: Zack Grienke (107), Max Scherzer (98), Paul Goldschmidt (72)

The Snakes are in rougher shape than the three teams behind them. Despite at least three-quarters of a HoME career among Grienke, Scherzer, and Goldschmidt, there’s nothing else brewing. It’s enough to stave off the Fish, at least. You know maybe if Taijuan Walker and Archie Bradley develop quickly, the team could add to this list. And maybe if Densby Swanson…oh, never mind.

The Spiders’ Web!!! Now those four recent expansion teams are miles behind all other active franchises. In fact, they each fall under within The Spiders’ Web. That is, the total for the Cleveland Spiders, who have the highest number of HoMErs among all defunct franchises (1.60). The Rockies have a way out of that one, the other teams, well, it might take them some time…and some don’t have a clear path out yet.

As we move into the mid-20s in our rankings, with the Spiders’ Web behind them, how much can teams expect to move upward in the standings? And how quickly? At this position among the teams, there’s not much hope of catching the leaders, let alone leaping into the top-ten. But no expansion team has gotten past the Ring of 16 (which we’ll talk about in our next post), the teams of the original AL/NL setup. Do they have a path to make that leap and maybe draw a bead on the bottom of the top tier?

Seattle Mariners

  • HoMErs:Edgar Martinez (100%), Ken Griffey, Jr. (64%), Randy Johnson (45%), Pat Gillick (15%), Dick Williams (12%), Gaylord Perry (6%), Rickey Henderson (3%), Goose Gossage (3%)
  • Retired: Alex Rodriguez (172), John Olerud (99), Cliff Lee (95), Mark Langston (95)
  • Active:Robinson Cano (120), Adrian Beltre (115), Ichiro (102), Felix Hernandez (98), Kyle Seager (73)

The Mariners are within a half a career of four other teams. Among their retirees, only A-Rod (29%) has an undeniable shot at our Hall. But Beltre (about 30%) and Ichiro (about 70%) will soon follow, so that the Boatsmen might have more than 1.3 careers to tack on by 2025. That would get them to about 4.0 full careers’ worth of HoME players, a figure that would currently place #19. But the winds are in their favor over the longer haul too. Cano will bring at least a quarter of a career if not a half, Felix (minimum 70% if he sails away soon), and maybe half of Seager will help them ride the crest of the tide. That’s another possible career and a half. The Seattleites, then could push upwards of 5.0 to 5.5 careers. Still outside the Ring of Sixteen but ready to fire the proverbial shot across the bow.

Toronto Blue Jays

  • HoMErs:Dave Stieb (99%), Pat Gillick (63%), Roberto Alomar (30%), Paul Molitor (15%), Bobby Cox (14%), Roger Clemens (10%), Frank Thomas (7%), David Cone (6%), Dave Winfield (5%), Jeff Kent (2%), Rickey Henderson (2%), Tony Phillips (1%), Phil Niekro (+0%)
  • Retired:  Roy Halladay (122), Scott Rolen (115), John Olerud (99), Mark Buehrle (98)
  • Active: Russell Martin (93), Troy Tulowitzki (86), Josh Donaldson (85), Jose Bautista (82), David Price (75)

Halladay (75% a Jay) and Rolen (10%) should be HoMErs quickly. Buehrle has a shot. But all of the active players have a question mark or two. Martin appears to be losing his bat and might not make it across the finish line. Tulo’s body (as mentioned above) is reliably unreliable, and he still has a lot of HoMEwork to do entering his 30s. Josh Donaldson’s remarkable career path guarantees nothing going forward. Jose Bautista looks cooked. Even David Price has a scary injury this year. The Jays could really cash in and leap forward or they could end up with only Halladay and Rolen likely to contribute. That’s about 1 player’s worth, which isn’t enough to keep the Mariners at bay, but is enough to fly by two of the teams directly ahead.

Milwaukee Brewers

  • HoMErs: Robin Yount (100%), Paul Molitor (69%), Ted Simmons (29%), Sal Bando (27%), Gary Sheffield (11%), Don Sutton (10%), Hank Aaron (6%), Willie Randolph (5%), Jim Edmonds (3%), Jimmy Wynn (2%)
  • Retired:  Jim Sundberg (96), Harry Dalton
  • Active: Zack Grienke (107), Ryan Braun (90)

Sorry, Brewers fans, but your future outlook for the HoME is worse than a flat Milwaukee’s Best from the can. You’ll very soon be the 26th best team as you’re passed by Seattle and Toronto, and you don’t have much ammunition to fire back and catch up. Especially not long term. But we can always drink to the memory of Harvey’s Wallbangers.

Texas Rangers

  • HoMErs:Ivan Rodriguez (60%), Rafael Palmeiro (56%), Kevin Brown (41%), Buddy Bell (40%), Fergie Jenkins (32%), Nolan Ryan (15%), Gaylord Perry (15%), Bert Blyleven (9%), Bobby Bonds (7%), Whitey Herzog (6%), Sammy Sosa (5%), Kenny Lofton (4%), Goose Gossage (2%), Willie Davis (2%)
  • Retired: Alex Rodriguez (172), Andruw Jones (115), Vlad Guerrero (101), Will Clark (101), Jim Sundberg (96), Lance Berkman (95), Cliff Lee (95)
  • Active: Adrian Beltre (115), Carlos Beltran (115), Cole Hamels (101), Roy Oswalt (101), Ian Kinsler (99), Jon Daniels

The Rangers lassoed the Spiders as the 1990s teams came through the electoral pipeline, and they’ve got some serious opportunities to flash their badges. A-Rod, Andruw, and the Impaler give the Metroplex Marshalls about 40% of a career if they get a plaque. All those active players could add about a career to that. Depending on how things pan out for the teams above them, the team could get into the top 20 within 15 years.

Washington Nationals

  • HoMErs:Gary Carter (67%), Tim Raines (60%), Andre Dawson (57%), Larry Walker (33%), Pedro Martinez (28%), Dick Williams (24%), Davey Johnson (17%), Willie Davis (7%), Ivan Rodriguez (5%), Pete Rose (2%), Randy Johnson (1%), Graig Nettles (1%)
  • Retired:  Mark Langston (95)
  • Active: Max Scherzer (98), Bartolo Colon (86), Bryce Harper (59), Dusty Baker

Like their real-life political counterparts in DC, the Nats appear to have a bumpy road HoME ahead of them. Scherzer is an odds-on favorite for a plaque, and he’d chip in 25% of a career. There simply aren’t a ton of good, projectable options after that. It’s very early in Bryce Harper’s career, and he’s had only one great season. Anyway, he’s likely leaving town as soon as Scott Boras can get that $400 million. I don’t know, maybe Jordan Zimmerman or Stephen Strassburg has an amazing run into his late 30s? The M’s, Jays, and Rangers are all hot on their tail, and this squad could also easily find themselves in 25th place, snuggling uncomfortably close to the Brewers. I don’t think it’ll get that bad for them, however, because our next team is losing ground even more rapidly.

San Diego Padres

  • HoMErs: Tony Gwynn (100%), Dave Winfield (37%), Ozzie Smith (24%), Dick Williams (21%), Roberto Alomar (19%), Goose Gossage (16%), Buzzie Bavasi (16%), Graig Nettles (13%), Willie McCovey (12%), Rickey Henderson (11%), Gaylord Perry (9%), Gary Sheffield (8%), Kevin Brown (8%), Greg Maddux (7%), Mike Piazza (6%), Willie Davis (5%), Jim Edmonds (1%)
  • Retired:  Gene Tenace (102), Mark Langston (95%)
  • Active: Adrian Gonzalez (85), Bruce Bochy

We don’t need to see any good players. They can go about their boring losing. Move along. Move along…to a battle with the Nats and Brewers for the 26th spot.

So as you can see, some teams are on the move, while several are drifting. Next time out, we’ll look at the last four expansion franchises and then see how things look inside the Ring of Sixteen.

  • Will a Johnny-come-lately expansion squad crash the Sweet 16 HoME soiree?
  • Which Ring of Sixteener is in a HoME hole?
  • Can anyone stop The Joker’s latest fiendish plot to sow chaos and fear in the hearts and minds of the people of Gotham City?

Tune in next time when you’ll hear Eric say, “Yah know, that’s a heck of a pickle they got themselves into.”

Maybe the Win Shouldn’t Die

Brian Kenny, Ahead of the CurveFor a number of years MLB Network’s Brian Kenny has been on a campaign to kill the Win. And he’s been joined by pretty much everyone who understands the game. I’m guessing Harold Reynolds is a holdout, and I have to guess because I don’t watch too much of the MLB Network these days. Anyway, it might not surprise you to know that I’ve been with Kenny and others from the start. But I’m beginning to have second thoughts. Let me explain.

We can only judge whether a statistic is good or bad in relation to other stats, right? In fact, we can only judge whether anything – a movie, restaurant, or science fair project – is good or bad when we compare it to others of its ilk.

We’re against the win because pitchers can get them when they pitch awfully, and they can fail to earn them when they twirl gems. But we’re talking about something that happens on the individual game level. Why is it that we make a big deal, or any deal at all, about something that happens in individual games?

Nobody is particularly impressed if a pitcher posts a 1.35 ERA or a hitter drives in three runs in a particular game. We understand that those things happen with great frequency, so they’re generally non-issues. We also don’t freak out if a pitcher gives up three bloop hits and a double off the wall. And it’s not the end of the world if a hitter comes up twice in a game with men on second and third only to be robbed by two great defensive plays by outfielders. Luck and random variation both happen.

Yet, we’re somehow fixated on the Win.

I’m here to tell you that Wins have value as a statistic, at least on a career level. And we shouldn’t kill it if it’s no worse than other mainstream statistics. In this pithy analysis, I’m going to look at all-time leaders in some mainstream statistical categories to see what kind of HoME membership is contained therein.

It’s possible that we can look at the Win a little differently than Kenny does. It’s possible that Wins aren’t so bad a stat relative to other mainstream measures we respect or at least stomach.


Each of the top 19 guys on the all-time Wins list is in the Hall of Miller and Eric. It’s not until #20 where we reach 307 game winner, Mickey Welch, that we find a hurler not in the HoME. Then things get a little dicey. Bobby Mathews clocks in at #25, Tommy John is #26, and Tony Mullane is tied for #29. Jim Kaat is #31, Burleigh Grimes is tied for #33, Jamie Moyer is #35, Eppa Rixey is #37, and Jim McCormick is #39. Then there’s Gus Weyhing at #40, Jack Morris tied for #43, Al Spalding at #46, and Jack Quinn at #49.

Whoa! Maybe I’m making a mistake. By my count, that’s 13 of the top 50 on the all-time wins chart who aren’t in the HoME. But let’s see how this list compares to others before we, like many, just dismiss the Win.


Mickey Lolich is #18 on the list. Then there’s Frank Tanana at #21, Jerry Koosman at #29, Javier Vazquez at #30, A.J. Burnett at #31, as well as Jack Morris, Mark Langston, Jim Kaat, Sam McDowell, Andy Pettitte, and Jamie Moyer at #34-39. Bartolo Colon is #44, Charlie Hough is #45, and Dwight Gooden is #50. Let’s not count Pettitte since he has a shot at HoME induction.

So we’re looking at 13 out of 50. Exactly the same as our Wins guys. Maybe we should kill the Strikeout?


I’m just including this category to be a pain in the ass. Trevor Hoffman, the #2 guy on the list, isn’t in the HoME. Neither are 46 others. The only guys who are in or going are Marino Rivera at #1, Dennis Eckersley at #7, and Rich Gossage at #23. That means 47 of the top 50 are out of the HoME. But we all know Saves are a terrible statistic already, much worse than the Win. Maybe we should try the Goose Egg?

And we’d have to agree if we could keep just one statistic, it would be the Win rather than the Save.

Batting Average

Much of this all-time list is outside the HoME, including #4, Lefty O’Doul. In fact, 21 of the top-50 Batting Average leaders are outside the HoME. However, we really should look at a more recent sample of players to learn if this is a bad statistic. Batting averages were different over 120 years ago, so I’m just going to look at the World Series era.

O’Doul is now #3 on the list. And we’re down to just 13 of 50. Of course, it’s not like 13 is so far 13 on the Wins list. I’m no math expert, but I think 13 is exactly the same.

Home Runs

We see the same problem on the all-time Home Runs list that we see on others. Relatively early on the list there’s a guy who’s not in the HoME. In this case it’s #12, Harmon Killebrew. David Ortiz at #21, sadly, isn’t going either. Same with Fred McGriff at #28, Willie Stargell at #30, Carlos Delgado at #32, Adam Dunn at #35, Jose Canseco at #36, Dave Kingman at #42, Jason Giambi at #43, Paul Konerko at #44, and Juan Gonzalez at #47. Additionally, I think it could be some time before #39, Vladimir Guerrero, gets in. That all depends on what Hall voters do, particularly those on the Era Committees.

All told we have 11 or 12 of 50 not in the HoME. Again, that’s not far from the 13 on the Wins list.

Runs Batted In

It’s not as vociferous a crowd who wants to dump the RBI, but we have to admit that opportunity is the driving force behind driving in runs. And the all-time list suggests to me that teams do a decent job of finding the right guys to give those RBI opportunities. It’s not until #21 where we find David Ortiz, deeper than any list thus far. Tony Perez is #28, Harold Baines is #30, Harmon Killebrew is #36, Fred McGriff is #42, Willie Stargell is #45, and Carlos Delgado is #50. That’s only seven guys in the top 50 who aren’t in the HoME. And the truth is that a few of them would be in if they did anything other than hit well. Hooray for Runs Batted In!


Johnny Damon clocks in at #25, and he’s never going to be a HoMEr. Lou Brock is #36. And that’s it! The other 48 guys on the list are all in the Hall of Miller and Eric. Forget ribbies, hooray for Runs!


Lou Brock is #23 on this list, Omar Vizquel is #36, Harold Baines is #39, Johnny Damon is #48, and Vada Pinson is #50. So compared to Hits and Runs, at least by this measure, Wins is a pretty bad statistical measure.


Dave Orr is #14, Charlie Keller is tied at #31, Gavvy Cravath is tied at #33, and Charley Jones is tied at #35. Elmer Flick, Benny Kauff, and Ralph Kiner are tied at +37. Sam Thompson is tied at #42, and of the eight guys tied at #49, only one is a HoMEr. Active players on the list include Mike Trout, Joey Votto, Albert Pujols, Miguel Cabrera, and Paul Goldschmidt. Most of those guys are fine, but Goldschmidt still has work to do. And Votto is older than some think at 33. Should he fall off the map in the next year or two, he likely won’t make it. That’s a minimum of nine guys. It’s ten if you count two of the tie for #49, and it’s 11 if you count one of Votto and Goldschmidt. I certainly believed OPS+ would be considerably more telling than Wins, but at 11 compared to 13, it isn’t.


This list is littered with olde tyme dudes and relief pitchers. There are two dozen who aren’t in and aren’t going.


If we’re looking as WAR by position players, every single guy is either in the HoME or going. Except maybe Chase Utley. I have him #22, a place where we might or might not support him. I believe Eric likes him more than I do, so he’s going to go.

Pitcher WAR

Well, we have Jim McCormick at #27, Mickey Welch at #44, Tommy John and Dazzy Vance tied at #47, and Bobby Mathews at #49. That’s five guys, more than as on the Runs list and as many as on the Hits list.

Shortcomings and Conclusions

Clearly a shortcoming of this study is that the HoME is a WAR-based institution. We start with a bias toward WAR as a strong statistic. On the other hand, it’s not like the list of pitcher WAR is even as good as the list of Hits or Runs.

My conclusion is this – the Win shouldn’t die. At least not as long as we still use other mediocre measures to help us interpret performance. Omnibus stats like WAR are great, but even WAR needs context. Should we timeline? Should we adjust for shorter schedules? How should we weigh peak and prime versus career?

There’s no easy answer, and that’s why just ignoring a statistic, any statistic, probably isn’t the best idea. Long live the Win! Maybe.




Institutional History

%d bloggers like this: